Human Rights
Contents
At a Glance
Preface to the Second Edition
Preface to the First Edition
Contents at a Glance
Detailed Contents
Abbreviation
Table of Cases
1. Human Rights—Some Concepts
2. Interpretation of Statutes
3. Equality and Gender Equality
4. Human Rights and Reservations for Backward Classes and Scheduled Tribes
5. Right to Conceive and Right to Abortion
6. Rights of the Unborn Child
7. Human Rights and the Child
8. Human Rights and Child Marriages
9. Human Rights and Child Prostitution
10. Human Rights and Child Exploitation
11. Human Rights and Child Labour
12. Rights of Adoption
13. Human Rights and Juveniles
14. Human Rights and Right to Life
15. Right to Dignity, Reputation and Status in Life
16. Right to Die and Euthanasia
17. Human Rights and Bonded Labour
18. Human Rights and Crimes against Women
19. Human Rights and Environmental, Air and Water Pollution
20. Human Rights and Democracy
21. Human Rights and Right to Freedom of Speech and Expression
22. Right to Information
23. Human Rights and the Media
24. Human Rights and Education
25. Human Rights and Freedom of Religion
26. Human Rights and Inter-Caste and Inter-Religion Marriages
27. Right of Cohabitation
28. Right to Health and Medical Care
29. Right to Smoke
30. Rights of Persons suffering from AIDS
31. Right to Profession and Trade
32. Human Rights and Consumerism
33. Right to Advertise
34. Human Rights and Right to Move Freely
35. Right to Passport and Travel Abroad
36. Right to Shelter
37. Right to Privacy
38. Public Wrongs and Public Interest Litigation
39. Human Rights and Citizenship
40. Human Rights of Foreigners
41. Human Rights of Refugees
42. Rights of Defence Personnel
43. Human Rights and Communal Riots
44. Human Rights in the Terrorised Areas
45. Rights in Emergency
46. Property and Easement Rights
47. Intellectual Property Rights
48. Human Rights and Advocates
49. Human Rights and Role of Police
50. Human Rights and Judiciary
51. Human Rights and Role of Criminal Courts
52. Human Rights and Personal Liberty
53. Right to Silence
54. Right to Legal Aid
55. Right to Speedy Trial
56. Handcuffing
57. Arrest and Detention
58. Search and Seizure
59. Bail and Remand
60. Human Rights and Torture in Police Custody
61. Custodial Deaths
62. Police Encounters
63. Rights of Accused Persons
64. Punishment for Crime
65. Human Rights of Prisoners and Jail Reforms
66. Voting Rights of Prisoners
67. Compensation for Violation of Human Rights
68. Words, Phrases and Legal Terms
APPENDIX 1 The Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993
APPENDIX 2 The National Human Rights Commission (Procedure) Regulations, 1994
APPENDIX 3 Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948
APPENDIX 4 International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, 1966
APPENDIX 5 International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966
Appendix 6 International Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Racial Discrimination, 1966
Appendix 7 American Convention of Human Rights, 1969
Appendix 8 African Charter on Human Rights and Peoples’ Rights, 1981
Appendix 9 Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (1966)
Appendix 10 Second Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, Aiming at the Abolition of Death Penalty (1989)
Appendix 11 Instrument of Accession by India to the Human Rights Covenants (1979)
Appendix 12 The National Commission for Minorities Act, 1992
Appendix 13 The National Commission For Minority Educational Institutions Act, 2004
APPENDIX 14 The National Commission for Women Act, 1990
APPENDIX 15 The Protection of Women From Domestic Violence Act, 2005
APPENDIX 16 The National Commission for Backward Classes Act, 1993
APPENDIX 17 The National Commission for Safai Karamcharis Act, 1993
APPENDIX 18 The Commission of Sati (Prevention) Act, 1987
APPENDIX 19 The Commission of Sati (Prevention) Rules, 1988
APPENDIX 20 The Commissions for Protection of Child Rights Act, 2005
APPENDIX 21 Constitution of India
APPENDIX 22 The Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955
APPENDIX 23 The Protection of Civil Rights Rules, 1977
APPENDIX 24 The Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989
APPENDIX 25 Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Rules, 1995
APPENDIX 26 The Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Act, 1995
APPENDIX 27 The Persons with Disabilities (Equal Protection of Opportunities,Rights and Full Participation) Rules, 1996
APPENDIX 28 The Pre-Natal Diagnostic Techniques (Regulation and Prevention of Misuse) Act, 1994
APPENDIX 29 The Consumer Protection Act, 1986
APPENDIX 30 The Right to Information Act, 2005
APPENDIX 31 The Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006
Subject- index
contents
CHAPTER 1
Human Rights—Some Concepts
1. Rights and Duties—Conceptual features
2. "Human rights"—Concept and Meaning of
3. History of the Human Rights movement
4. Gradual Development of the Protection of Human Rights
5. Human rights—A vibrant issue
6. Worldwide acceptance of the ideology of Human rights
7. Human rights represent a vital expression of values
8. Universal influence of human rights movement
9. Universality about Human Rights
10. "International Covenants"—Meaning of
11. Historical background of Human Rights of Women
12. Directive Principles and Fundamental Rights—Reconciliation between
13. Universal Declaration of Human Rights
14. Human rights—Individual as the focal point
15. Necessity of tolerance
16. "Life"—Meaning of
17. Right to live with human dignity
18. Article 21 of the Constitution enjoins every person’s entitlement to life
19. Free Legal aid movement
20. Curtailment of personal liberty and freedom
21. Decency and dignity—Non-negotiable facets of human rights
22. Court an umpire to protect human rights
23. National Human Rights Commission
24. Approach to Court for enforcement of fundamental rights
25. Access to justice
26. Criminal justice process and participation of the victim
27. Provision of personal security by the State
28. Relief for violation of Article 21 of the Constitution
29. Personal liberty and due process of law
30. Mass agitations and restraints on personal liberty
31. Intrusion into privacy
32. Right to life includes right to livelihood
33. Conservation of precincts of historical value
34. Right to shelter—A basic right
35. Rehabilitation of disabled persons
36. Fundamental Right for speedy trial conferred by Article 21 of the Constitution
37. Rights to speedy and expeditious criminal trial
38. Right to work
39. Right to carry on an occupation
40. Regulation of traffic and levy of parking fees
41. Special status to Scheduled Castes
42. Slavery—Its causes and prohibition
43. Flag Code of India—Observance of
44. Hoisting of National Flag by citizens on their premises
45. Rights of the living dead
46. Training and exhibition of animals
47. Camels—Slaughtering of
48. Trade in ivory or ivory articles
49. Infringement of Human Rights—Writ for compensation
50. Fundamental Duties
CHAPTER 2
Interpretation of Statutes
1. Concept of interpretation
2. Interpretation—Meaning of
3. Interpretation—Object of
4. Purpose of
5. Primary principle of interpretation
6. Validity of legislative enactment with reference to Article 19
7. Constitutional validity of statutes—Determination
8. Writ jurisdiction—Court not to decide academic issues
9. Beneficent legislation
10. Title of the Act
11. Preamble as an aid to interpretation
12. General principles of interpretation of statutes
13. Fundamental rules of interpretation
14. Cardinal rule of interpretation
15. Golden Rule
16. Clear and unambiguous language
17. Casus omissus
18. Casus Omissus—Whether permissible to supply
19. Equity of the statute
20. Harmonious interpretation
21. Purposive construction
22. Commencement of an Act
23. Notification
24. Intention of Legislature
25. Reasons of enactment
26. Policy and object of the statute
27. Historical facts
28. Recommendations of the Law Commission
29. Statement of Objects and Reasons
30. Statement of Objects and Reasons—Use of, for deciding constitutionality of a Statute
31. Determination of object of statute
32. Rule of construction
33. Object of, and words and phrases
34. Common commercial meaning of the words
35. Same word to have same meaning
36. Effect to words used
37. Each word is important
38. Two different expressions
39. Definition clause
40. Context
41. Grammatical construction
42. Punctuation
43. Courts cannot legislate
44. Courts cannot rewrite a section
45. Heading of the section
46. Interpretation—Inclusive definition
47. Adjectives
48. Use of Adjectives—Function of qualitative adjective
49. Ejusdem generis rule
50. Assistance of statutes in pari materia
51. Incorporation of the provisions of another statute
52. Conflict between two similar statutes
53. Generalia specialibus non-derogant
54. Constitutional validity of a statute
55. Contemporanea expositio
56. Doctrine of severability
57. Dictionary Meanings
58. Encyclopaedias and technological books
59. Marginal Notes
60. Explanation
61. Schedule
62. Illustration
63. Non obstante clause
64. Internal aids
65. External aids
66. Doctrine of pith and substance
67. Delegated legislation
68. Subordinate legislation
69. Provision creating legal fiction
70. Deeming provision
71. Directory or mandatory provision
72. Exception
73. Saving clause
74. Proviso
75. General and particular powers
76. Executive instructions
77. Bye-laws of co-operative society—Do not have status of a statute
78. Amending Act
79. Repeal of a statute
80. Amendment and repeal
81. Prospectivity and Retrospectivity
82. Effect of amendment on pending proceedings
83. Implied repeal
84. Doctrine of eclipse
85. Doctrine of prospective overruling
86. Prospective operation of judgment
87. Binding nature of decision
88. Precedents
89. Precedent—Decision in election petition
90. Construction by implication of a notification
91. Construction of judgment
92. Res judicata
93. Defect in a notification
94. Taxing and Fiscal statutes
95. Penal statutes
96. Remedial statute
97. Procedural law
98. Interpretation of compromise decree
99. Interpretation of the Constitution
100. Interpretation of documents
101. Policy document
102. Interpretation of declaratory statute
103. Pre-Constitution enactment—Constitutionality of
104. Order passed contrary to mandatory provision of statute
CHAPTER 3
Equality and Gender Equality
1. Concept of equal treatment does not countenance reputation of wrong action
2. Directive Principles
3. Equality—Legal and Real
4. Inequality not favourable to fraternity
5. Dignity and equality of status and opportunity
6. Equal protection clause
7. Equality before Law—Concept of
8. Affirmative action and reservation
9. Service tax—Imposition of
10. Classification in regard to retrial/pensionary benefits
11. Protective umbrella of reservation
12. Public employment and equality of opportunity
13. Parity in promotional avenues
14. Fixation of seniority
15. Correction of date of birth in service records
16. Disciplinary proceedings
17. Pay revision
18. Fixation of different dates for extending benefit of enhanced stipend
19. Transfer
20. Termination of services of probationer
21. Regularisation of services of probationer
22. Determination of seniority of probationer
23. Appointment—Lack of transparency
24. Appointment—Discrimination
25. "Increment" and "Pay revision"—Distinguished
26. Termination of services of Badli worker
27. Appointment to sensitive posts
28. Appointment—False information given in application form—Rejection of candidature
29. Appointment—Reservation of posts of District Munsifs for women
30. Regularisation
31. Promotion
32. Ad hoc promotion
33. Deputationist—Reversion of
34. Correction of date of birth
35. Transfer—Political interference
36. Transfer—Interference by Court
37. Transfer of army personnel—Interference by Courts
38. Resignation
39. Equality of status and of opportunity
40. Classification
41. Policy decision—Must be made fairly
42. Unfair and irrational clause in a contract
43. Contract for supply of High Security Registration Plates for motor vehicles—Tender for
44. Judicial review in the matter of contracts
45. Article 226—Disputes relating to contracts
46. Submission of tender documents
47. Tender conditions—To be adhered to scrupulously
48. Fixation of pre-qualifications of tenderers
49. Government contract—Insertion of new eligibility criteria in tender notice
50. Government contract—Avoidance of payment of admitted amount
51. Government contract—Scope of judicial review
52. Government contract—Issuance of tender—Requirement
53. Affirmative action as compensatory and distributive justice
54. Arbitrariness and equality
55. Reasonableness and fair play
56. Charging different rates for mutation of property
57. Law as an instrument of social and distributive justice
58. Equal pay for equal work
59. Pay scale—Entitlement
60. Egalitarian Society and doctrine of equality
61. Discrimination implies deprivation
62. Adoption of measures of affirmative discrimination in favour of women
63. Competing claims
64. Fundamental Rights
65. Regulatory statute
66. Equality to the child
67. Custody of minor child
68. Categorisation of prisoners
69. Gender equality—A basic human right
70. Problem of gender equality
71. Judicial response to gender justice
72. Discrimination on grounds of gender
73. Prescription of Dress Code for Nurses in Indian Military Nursing Service
74. Retirement age of female members of aircraft flying crew
75. Sensitivity towards gender bias
76. Female education and gender equality
77. Rights to degraded women under the Constitution
78. Framing Code of Conduct is a right of the State
79. Basic economic rights to women in the family
80. Sexual harassment
81. Violation of fundamental rights of gender equality
82. Effective enforcement of basic rights of gender equality
83. Measures to check sexual harassment of working women
CHAPTER 4
Human Rights and Reservations for
Backward
Classes and Scheduled Tribes
1. Secularism
2. Concept of "Secularism"
3. "Class" and "Caste"—Meaning of
4. Class of citizen does not include caste or religion
5. Caste system in India
6. Any backward class of citizen—Interpretation of
7. Backward classes and Backward class of citizens—Difference between
8. Article 16 (4) relates not to backward class but ‘class of citizen inadequately represented in service’
9. Poverty and social backwardness
10. Backward Class—Criteria for identification
11. Caste—Determination of
12. Caste certificate
13. Scheduled Tribes—Considerations for issue of caste certificate
14. Admission on basis of Caste Certificate
15. False caste certificate
16. Appointment on the basis of false caste certificate—Termination of service
17. Equity jurisdiction—Exercise of
18. Cancellation of Caste Certificate
19. Right of equality to Harijan and abolition of untouchability
20. Offence of insult on the ground of untouchability
21. Neglect of duties of public servant in conduct of investigation
22. Classification
23. Classification on the basis of educational qualifications
24. Classification due to historical reasons
25. Classification due to geographical reasons
26. Objectives of Reservations
27. Fraternity and reservation
28. Reservation—A means to offset inequality and achieve equality
29. Representation and its adequacy
30. Reservation—Test of reasonableness
31. Reservation and Preference—Substantially different concepts
32. Identification of creamy layer in backward class
33. Positive and affirmative action and positive discrimination—Concept of
34. SC/ST Reservation benefits—In education and public employment
35. Whether the policy of the Government can be subjected to judicial review ?
36. Extent of judicial review
37. Issuance of writ for reservation under Article 16 (4)
38. Status of SC/ST persons upon migration to another State
39. Reservation provisions attracted till before Constitution (77th Amendment) Act, 1995 and Constitution (81st Amendment) Act, 2000 only at the stage of initial appointment
40. Job reservation and promotion before the aforesaid two Constitution Amendment Acts
41. Future vacancy does not attract reservation
42. Procedural fairness in selection procedure
43. Protective reservation in super-speciality courses
44. Claim in maintenance of efficiency of Administration
45. Ignorance of merit on quantum of handicapness
46. Judicial review of reservation
47. Judicial Officers Cadre and Reservation Rule
48. Author’s submission
CHAPTER 5
Right to Conceive and Right to Abortion
1. Right to procreation of children
2. Right of abortion
3. Abortion right : A part of woman’s rights
4. Abortion : When permissible?
5. Protection of foetus in the gestation period
6. Religious view point on abortion
(A) Christianity
(B) Islam
(C) Hinduism
7. Abortion or killing foetus is a sin
8. Protectable interest of the foetus
9. Abortion cannot be forced on minor girl
10. Minor girl—Right to marriage and to conceive
11. Conflicting nature of right to conception, right to abortion and right to birth
CHAPTER 6
Rights of the Unborn Child
1. Status of the unborn child
2. Child in a womb regarded as a person in existence
3. Equal protection to unborn offspring
4. Right of the unborn child to birth
5. Sons born after partition
6. Son en ventre sa mere
7. Right to object to alienation of property
CHAPTER 7
Human Rights and the Child
1. Introductory
2. Pre-natal diagnostic techniques to determine the sex
3. Legitimacy/Paternity of the child
4. Illegal sale of babies—Procedural safeguard
5. Imposition of corporal punishment on the child
6. Children as victims of crime—The International scenario
7. Children as victims of crime—Its dimensions
8. Violence against children
9. Sexual exploitation of children
CHAPTER 8
Human Rights and Child Marriages
1. "Child Marriage"—Connotation of
2. Marriage of Minor—Restraint and prohibition
3. Child marriage—Legality and validity of
4. Child marriage—A social evil
5. Issuance of directions by Court
CHAPTER 9
Human Rights and Child Prostitution
1. Prostitution—Meaning of
2. Human rights and prostitution
3. Prostitution in society
4. Factors which support prostitution
5. Sexual child abuse
6. Child prostitutes
7. Concern of Judiciary towards sexual abuse
8. Sexual exploitation of children—Court’s directions
9. Genesis of the problem of prostitution
10. "Brothel"—Meaning of
11. Rehabilitation of prostitutes
12. Economic rehabilitation for prevention of prostitution
13. Measures to retrieve women from prostitution
14. Amendment of Dowry Prohibition Act—Steps to curb exploitation and suppression of women
15. Rescue and rehabilitation of child prostitutes
CHAPTER 10
Human Rights and Child Exploitation
1. Concern for the welfare of children
2. Problem of population explosion
3. Exploitation of children in any form is objectionable
4. Use of children by criminal gangs
CHAPTER 11
Human Rights and Child Labour
1. Problem of child labour
2. Causes of failure of legislative measures to eliminate child labour
3. Employing child labour is an offence
4. Child labour—Compensation to be paid by offending employer
5. Public interest litigation—Child labour in match factory
6. Child labour in hazardous employment—Prohibition of
CHAPTER 12
Rights of Adoption
1. Adoption—What is ?
2. Adoption—Right and necessity
3. Adoption—A religious duty
4. Custom as a source of right of Adoption
5. Article 21 as a source of right of Adoption
6. Method of Adoption in England
7. General effect of Adoption
8. Jurisdiction of the English Courts in matters of Adoption
(i) General rules
(ii) Convention rules
9. Validity of Adoption
10. Adoption under International Law
11. Law of Adoption in England
12. Law of Adoption in U.S.A.
13. Law of Adoption in India
14. Adoption—Validity of
15. Adoption by a Hindu converted to Christianity
16. Adoption and marriage
17. Proprietary effect of Adoption
18. Adoption and inheritance
19. Alienation of property—Right of adopted son
20. Doctrine of "relation-back"
CHAPTER 13
Human Rights and Juveniles
1. General
2. Objects of the Juvenile Justice Act
3. Aims of juvenile justice
4. Development of child’s personality
5. Delinquent juvenile and neglected juvenile
6. Method to rehabilitate neglected juvenile
7. Child Welfare Officer and Superintendent of the Observation Home—Qualities in
8. Proof of age
9. Powers of Sessions Judge to determine whether a person is juvenile
10. Juveniles—Trial by ordinary Court
11. Protection against exploitation of child
12. Question of age of juvenile—Determination of
13. Conviction when child becomes major
14. Criminal trials of children
15. Plea of minority—When to be taken
16. Jurisdiction of Criminal Courts in offences punishable with death or life imprisonment
17. Juvenile Courts—Judicial Officers must have some special training
18. Reformation—Theory of
19. Remand home and observation homes—Status of
20. Reformatory school not meant for major
CHAPTER 14
Human Rights and Right to Life
1. Duties and functions of the State
2. Right to life and liberty—Very wide in scope and applicability
3. Jurisprudence of personhood—Scope of
4. Life and liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution
5. Social justice—An arch to ensure meaningful life
6. Right to life—Facets of
7. Right to life—Payment of salary to employees of Public Sector Undertakings
8. Entitlement of citizens to a life of dignity
9. Indecent beauty contest—Offence under Article 21 of the Constitution
10. Right to education is implicit in right to life
11. Rights for a decent life under Article 21 of the Constitution
12. Right to get water—A part of right to life
13. Right to dignified and civilised life—Problem of water logging
14. Provision of medical services in trains
15. Provision of adequate medical facilities
16. Freedom of movement—Provision for wearing protective head gear
17. Erection of advertisement hoardings—Regulation of
18. Right to life—Project of beautification and cleaning of river bed area
19. Reimbursement of medical expenses to a Government employee permissible
20. Deformity caused by polluted water—Free medical treatment
21. Right to move freely throughout the territory of India
22. Security of life of citizen—Freedom from fear and threat
23. Right to privacy
24. Right to shelter springs from right to residence
25. Protection of health of workmen
26. Licence for acquisition of firearms
27. Calling of "bundh" entails restriction of movement
28. Travel by sleeper coaches during day time by short distance commuters
29. Remand when sanction order bad
30. Notification banning the training and exhibition of animals in circuses—Whether violative of the right to life
CHAPTER 15
Right to Dignity, Reputation and Status in Life
1. Dignity—Explained
2. Right to status of tribals
3. Right to decent standard of life
4. Right of lunatic to get timely medical aid and treatment
CHAPTER 16
Right to Die and Euthanasia
1. Suicide
2. Causes for committing suicide
3. Right to die
4. Validity of Section 309, Indian Penal Code
5. Right to end one’s own life
6. Attempt to commit suicide—Section 305, I.P.C. not unconstitutional
7. Sufferings of persons and result as a failure of attempt to suicide
8. Suicide and social trauma
9. Suicide and Euthanasia—Distinguished
10. Euthanasia
CHAPTER 17
Human Rights and Bonded Labour
1. "Bonded labour"—Connotation of
2. Forced labour—Ambit and scope of
3. Begar is a form of forced labour
4. Act of depriving a person of the choice of alternatives is called ‘Force’
5. "Begar"—Meaning of
6. Bonded labourer—Identification and rehabilitation
7. Conscious obligation of employer not to force system of bonded labour
8. Relief by State in conditions of drought
9. Exploitation of migrant workmen and suo motu action by Supreme Court under Article 32 of the Constitution
CHAPTER 18
Human Rights and Crimes against Women
1. General
2. Women as victims of violence
3. "Traffic in human beings"
4. Violence against women
5. Rights of a Hindu wife
SEXUAL HARASSMENT
6. Sexual harassment of working women
7. Dignity of women upheld by the Apex Court
RAPE
8. General
9. Rape—Definition cannot be enlarged to include all forms of penetration
10. Presence of smegma
11. Medical examination of the victim
12. Rape case—Determination of age of prosecutrix
13. Necessity of corroboration of testimony of victim
14. Consent not proved—Conviction proper
15. No conviction without proper identification
16. Conviction sustained in absence of malice against the accused
17. Inference of consent
18. Rape—Measure of punishment
19. Reduction of custodial sentence
20. Rape—Reduction of sentence below prescribed minimum
21. Consent of minor will not be helpful if there is penetration
22. Consent of prosecutrix where medical evidence not supportive
23. Absence of corroboration
24. Delay in lodging of FIR
25. Disowning of FIR by the maker
26. Conviction set aside where evidence of prosecutrix unreliable
27. Identification of accused in rape cases
28. Evidence of resistance in rape cases
29. Modesty of a woman
30. Outraging of modesty
31. Attempt to rape and outraging of modesty of a woman—Distinction between
32. Forcible rubbing of penis though without penetration sufficient to prove an attempt to commit rape
33. Independent corroboration—Necessity of
34. Interference in finding of fact of lower Court —Illegal
35. Interim maintenance in bail order against accused
36. Non-corroboration of eye-witnesses—Fatal to prosecution
37. Statement of prosecutrix—Relevancy of
38. Absence of injuries on the prosecutrix
39. Testimony of prosecutrix when sufficient for conviction
deaths BY Burning
40. Bail to accused persons
41. Framing of alternative charge will not vitiate Court’s finding
42. Improper investigation of attacks on married women
43. Compounding of offence under Section 498-A, I.P.C. by the Court
44. Conviction for offence under Section 363, I.P.C
CRUELTY
45. "Cruelty"—Definition of
46. Absence of evidence in case of cruelty
47. Cruelty not proved in absence of wilful conduct and unlawful demand
48. "Cruelty"—"Legal cruelty" and "Mental cruelty"—Proof of
49. Danger not required to be proved in cruelty
50. Determination of cruelty—Factors for
51. Ill-treatment by in-laws causing death—Cruelty proved
52. Wife not staying with husband after marriage
53. Offence of cruelty—Misuse of against innocent husbands
54. Physical violence—Not necessary ingredient of cruelty
55. Cruelty and demand for dowry
56. Repeated demand of dowry—An act of cruelty
57. Modification of sentence
58. Sufficient evidence regarding demand of money—Guilt proved
59. Harassment by instituting false cases
60. Ingredients of offence of attempt to commit crime
61. Appreciation of evidence in suicide case
62. Absence of evidence—Offence not made out
63. Death of deceased caused in furtherance of common intention
64. Direction to pay compensation to deceased’s heir—Legality of
65. Death by hanging
66. Conviction for mental torture and cruelty
67. Proof of harassment established—Sufficient for conviction under Section 304-B, I.P.C
68. Report by Police Officer on completion of investigation
69. Nature of proof in dowry death cases
70. Suspicion and conjectures—Fatal to prove the guilt in case of dowry death
71. Dowry death—Time between ill-treatment and death is relevant
72. Modes and methods to commit suicide
73. Infliction of torture by husband not proved, conviction set aside
DIVORCE
74. Marriage and Divorce
75. Annulment of marriage—On grounds of fraud by suppression of material facts at time of marriage
76. Annulment of marriage—On grounds of mental disorder
77. Withdrawal of wife from the society of husband
78. Divorce—Ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage
79. Divorce petition—Grounds of desertion by wife
80. Desertion and wilful separation—Distinguished
81. Cruelty
82. Mental cruelty—Explained
83. Divorce on ground of cruelty
84. Divorce petition by Christian husband
MAINTENANCE
HINDU ADOPTIONS AND MAINTENANCE ACT, 1956
85. Right of maintenance
86. No conflict with restitution of conjugal rights
87. Desertion
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, Section 125
88. Right to claim maintenance from husband
89. Claim for maintenance on re-marriage of husband
90. Right to maintenance—Independent of personal law
91. Ability to maintain
92. Maintenance of mother
93. Maintenance case—Absence of affidavit
94. Claim of wife for additional maintenance amount
95. Allegations of adultery and cruelty
96. Maintenance amount
97. Application for change of maintenance allowance
98. Arrear of maintenance of more than one year—Power of court to grant
99. Attachment of salary for recovery of maintenance
100. Quantum of maintenance
101. Change of husband’s income during maintenance proceedings
102. Amount of maintenance—Circumstances to be considered
103. Claim for maintenance
104. Divorced but not remarried
105. Decree for restitution of conjugal relations—Effect of
106. Maintenance—Enhancement of
107. Grant of maintenance and allegations of adultery
108. Grant of maintenance allowance from date of application
109. Grant of maintenance to Muslim minor daughter on date of divorce—Permissibility of
110. Income of the husband
111. Inability to maintain—Imperative necessity to prove
112. Interference in amount of maintenance
113. Interim maintenance—Grant of
114. Interlocutory order and interim order—Interpretation of
115. Inflation of cost in maintenance—Judicial notice
116. Joint Hindu family—Liability for maintenance
117. Lump sum payment of maintenance
118. Maintenance on adjournments of case on several occasions
119. Maintenance allowance—Grant of
120. Maintenance granted by Civil Court—Effect of
121. Maintenance from the date of application—No bar
122. Proof of talaq and maintenance during iddat period
123. Maintenance pendente lite
124. Maintenance—No relationship with religion, caste or personal law
125. Father’s income—Irrelevant for fixing son’s liability for maintenance
126. Nature of proceedings for maintenance
127. Double maintenance allowance—Not permissible
128. Order for maintenance—Proof of neglect or refusal necessary
129. Mere occasional visit by husband—No proof of maintenance
130. Order to be passed after hearing both the parties
131. Offer by husband to maintain and refusal by wife
132. Offer to maintain cannot take effect retrospectively under Section 125 (3), Cr. P.C.
133. Wife may live separately on justifiable grounds and get allowance
134. Order for maintenance
135. Order from date of application
136. Grant of maintenance to wife and minor son
137. Power of Court to recover maintenance amount
138. Order passed without reason
139. Ex parte interim maintenance order
140. Who is liable to pay maintenance?
141. Private agreement to pay maintenance—No bar for proceedings
142. Reassessment of evidence in maintenance proceedings
143. Arrears of maintenance allowance—Recovery of
144. Wife living separately without sufficient cause
145. Second marriage entitles wife for separate living and maintenance
146. Second wife can claim maintenance
147. Effective date of payment of maintenance
148. Commencement of both civil and criminal proceedings for maintenance—Proceedings under Section 125, Cr. P.C.—Ought to be stayed
149. Arrears of maintenance—Abatement of
150. Facts to be proved in maintenance case
151. Inability to maintain
152. Affidavit—Validity of order on
153. Interim maintenance—Grant of
154. Maintenance order—When exhausted
155. Cancellation of orders for maintenance—Jurisdiction
Hindu Marriage Act
156. Maintenance pendente lite—Application can be disposed of on affidavits
157. Interim maintenance
158. Maintenance of child—Moral and statutory obligation
159. Maintenance pendente lite
160. Maintenance and litigation expenses
161. Obligation of maintenance of wife
162. Maintenance and validity of marriage
Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act, 1986
163. General
164. Maintenance allowance
165. Maintenance—A right or charity ?
166. Maintenance—Whether provisions are an eyewash ?
167. Maintenance under Muslim law—Oral divorce
168. Relief of maintenance under Muslim Act, 1986—Tenability of petition under Section 125, Cr. P.C. proceeding
169. Major girl—Marries of her choice—Charge sheet under Section 366/368, IPC quashed under Article 32 by Supreme Court
CHAPTER 19
Human Rights and Environmental, Air and
Water Pollution
General
1. Love of Nature
2. Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles providing for protection of environment—To be read together
3. Disturbance of basic environment elements—Hazardous to life
4. Environmental Pollution—Causes of
5. Pollution and nature-destruction crimes—Gravity of
6. Steps for controlling environmental pollution
7. Protection of people from pollution
8. Tapping of natural resources and ecological balance
9. Environmental care and conservation
10. Construction of Tehri Dam—Well-informed decision taken by Government not to abandon the project cannot be interfered with by Court
11. Environmental Courts/Tribunals—Difficulties of complex technology
12. Environmental Law and locus standi
13. Environmental protection—Consciousness for
14. Environmental Protection—A constitutional mandate and commitment
15. Society’s interaction with nature and effect on humanity
16. Environment safeguard under the Constitution
17. Free and unpolluted environment—Court’s intervention
18. Hygienic environment—An integral facet of right of healthy life
19. Land development plans
20. Industrial development vis-a-vis protection of environment
21. Nuisance—An interference in enjoyment
22. Necessity of policy decision for ecological balance
23. Establishment of forest based industries
24. Effects of pollution and nature-destruction crimes
25. Controlling the monster of pollution
26. Protective measures to control pollution
27. Precautions in laying pipeline to protect Ecology and Environment
28. Protection of life and personal liberty
29. Public nuisance by pollution of river Ganga
30. Public nuisance by manufacturing contaminated and adulterated tea
31. Adequacy of punishment for violation of Environmental Protection Laws
32. Safeguards under Article 32 for preservation of fundamental rights
33. Changing trends in judicial activism in environmental protection
34. Right to environment and right to livelihood flow from right to life
35. Right to Life—Manifold attributes
36. Protection and preservation of environmental ambience—Encroachment of indiscriminate construction of residential-cum-commercial complexes by Development Authority
37. Domestic garbage and sewage
38. Right to use water prevails over other needs
39. Atmospheric pollution—Slow poisoning by
40. Changing needs of the society—Evolution of New Law
41. Sustainable development
42. Sustainable Development and Ecology—A balancing concept
AIR POLLUTION
43. Air pollution defined
44. Effects of Air pollution
45. Air pollution control in residential area
46. Water and Air Acts—A complete Code for prevention and control of water and air pollution
47. Precautions to avoid Air pollution
48. Pollution by Alloy Steel rolling mill—Directions by Pollution Control Board
49. Exemption to industries causing air pollution—Ultra vires the Air Act
50. Relocation of industries to prevent annihilation of inhabitants
51. Banning of limestone quarries
52. Degradation of Taj due to pollution
53. Ban on old commercial vehicles
NOISE POLLUTION
54. Right to life—Includes freedom from noise pollution
55. Disastrous noise violative of constitutional guarantee under Article 21
56. Right to sleep and leisure
57. Interference of noise with sleep and rest
58. Health hazards of Noise pollution
59. Ban on manufacture of fireworks creating noise beyond permissible limits
60. No inherent right to manufacture fireworks that creates sound pollution
61. Sound pollution during Azan
62. Restrictions on use of loudspeakers/public address system—Exemption
63. Noise by aircrafts
64. Excessive noise—A war of decibels
65. Noise pollution by vehicles
WATER POLLUTION
66. Pollution of water
67. Pollution by health care establishments
68. Pollution by discharge of sewage into river
69. Shrimp culture farming
HIGHWAYS
70. Law relating to users of highways involves give and take
PLASTICS
71. Consumption of plastic and its effect
NEON LIGHTS
72. Neon lights—A source of health hazard and environmental nuisance
PRINCIPLES ON ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
73. General
74. Precautionary principle and the polluter pays principle
75. The precautionary principle—New burden of proof
76. The Assimilative Capacity Principle replaced by the Precautionary Principle
77. Salient principles of sustainable development
78. Customary International Law and Domestic Municipal Law
CLOSURE AND compensation
79. Closure of workshop
80. Compensation—Liability of polluting industries
81. Offence by Company
82. Lack of public response to pollution crimes
83. Public Interest Litigation for ecological imbalances
84. (i) "Natural resources are the assets of the entire nation"..... Guidelines fixed by Apex Court to determine N.P.V.
(ii) "The King is under no man, but under God and the law" The Apex Court convicts and sentences a Minister and a Secretary for Contempt of Court as they flouted Supreme Court's orders
CHAPTER 20
Human Rights and Democracy
1. Democratic Theory
2. Parliamentary system of democracy
3. Democratic Government
4. Parliamentary democracy and sovereignty
5. Executive action of Government
6. Election—Concept of
7. Democracy and elections
8. Election to local bodies—Reservation of seat for backward community
9. Right to elect—A statutory right
10. Election Commission—Role and powers of
11. Election Commission and Election Authorities—Governed by the Representation of the Peoples Act
12. Election Schedule
13. Delimitation of constituencies—Postponement of elections
14. Power of Election Commission to issue Election Symbols Order
15. Candidate when deemed to be set up by political party—Mechanism for ascertaining
16. Right of political party for reservation of symbol exclusively for it
17. Right to contest election to local bodies on a particular specified symbol
18. Qualifications for election to Municipal Council
19. Prohibition of independent candidate from joining any political party after his election—Not discriminatory
20. Right to know is a basic right
21. Right of voters to know and Supreme Court’s directions to Election Commission
22. Challenge to elections
23. Limitation for filing election petition
24. Election disqualification—Suspension of sentence and conviction against candidate seeking to contest election
25. Election disqualification—Fixing different periods of conviction and imprisonment for determining
26. Disqualification for election on grounds of bigamy
27. Disqualification to contest election—Ground of subsistence of contract with appropriate Government on date of filing of nomination and declaration of results
28. Municipality elections—Disqualifications
29. Disqualification for membership of Municipality
30. Right to contest election—Whether fundamental
31. Panchayat elections—Challenge to rejection of nomination paper
32. Disqualification for being member of Legislative Assembly—Ground of holding office of profit
33. Election petition—Material facts
34. Election disputes—Writ jurisdiction
35. Reservation of constituencies—Purpose of
36. Social justice—Arch to ensure life to be meaningful
37. Principles of social justice—When cannot be invoked
38. Restrictions upon the exercise of the right of liberty—Extent of
39. Theory and practice of two houses; Domicile in the State concerned no more needed
40. The Representation of Peoples (Amendment) Act No. 40 of 2003—Voting through open—Ballot in Council of States valid
41. Challenge to HCS notification appointing a Special Judge for trying former Chief Minister through a P.I.L., not permissible (Majority view)
42. Author’s submissions
CHAPTER 21
Human Rights and Right to Freedom of
Speech
and Expression
1. Right of free speech
2. Court is the custodian of rights of citizens
3. Suspension of Fundamental rights
4. New judicial approach in administration of justice
5. Right of freedom of expression
6. Exhibition of films on Doordarshan
7. Right to express views and sentiments
8. Freedom of speech under Article 19 (1) of the Constitution—Scope of
9. Freedom of assembly
10. Movies as a means of communication
11. Tax on entertainment—Power of State Government to levy tax on cable television
12. Freedom of propagation of ideas and views
13. Restrictions on freedom of expression
14. Prohibitory order to maintain communal harmony
15. Protection to literary activities
CHAPTER 22
Right to Information
1. Right to information—A fundamental right
2. Right to seek and receive information
3. Right to information with reference to elections
4. Courts as sentinel to protect fundamental rights
5. Right to information—Public interest vis a vis national and public security
6. Right to information about war
7. Right to information—Kargil infiltration
8. Restrictions on disclosure of information under the Atomic Energy Act, 1962
CHAPTER 23
Human Rights and the Media
1. Social justice and enforcement of laws
2. Press to cater to the communication needs of the society
3. Press in the role of a social scientist
4. Freedom of communication
5. Importance and responsibility of the press
6. Curtailment of the freedom of the press
7. Law reports—Whether a newspaper
8. Media reports and public advocacy
9. Right of propagation of views and ideas
10. Right to publish and circulate with complete freedom
11. Right to publish speech—Denial is violative of Article 19 (1) (a)
12. Freedom of Press
13. Freedom of Press—Trial by media
14. Control over newspapers by restricting advertisements
15. Importance of P.I.L. to control administrative actions
16. Legal literacy—A pre-condition to maintain rule of law
17. Justice achieved through Newspaper
18. Publication of illegal and false matter—Effect on Newspaper
19. Imposition of restrictions in interest of Public Order
20. Taking photographs of Court proceedings
21. Pre-censorship and restriction on Liberty of Press
22. Empanelment of Producers of Audio/Video Films/Sports—Eligibility criteria
23. Pre-censorship of films
24. Fitness of the film for certification
25. Restrictions in Cinematograph Act for screening of films
26. Restriction of publishing views in Newspaper
27. Investigative Reporting
28. Restriction may be put on Right of Association
29. Restriction on Right of Freedom of Speech—Impact on Newspapers
30. Levy of tax on newsprint
CHAPTER 24
Human Rights and Education
EDUCATION AS FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT
1. Directive Principles of State Policy and Fundamental Rights
2. Restrictions placed on Fundamental Rights to secure Directive Principles—Would be reasonable subject to certain limitation
3. Right to education—Implicit in right to life
4. Establishment of University—To provide consultancy, to establish examination centres, to institute degrees, diplomas, certificates, etc.—Not contemplated under the constitutional scheme
5. Right of child to education—Making primary education compulsory
6. Academic standards—Prescription of
7. Academic matters—Prescription of courses of study
8. Irregularities in admission
9. Admission to Super Speciality Course—Denial of admission
10. Falling educational standards and control of examination and results
11. Denial of permission to appear in examination
12. Malpractice by student in the examination—Enquiry against
13. Cancellation of examination results on ground of mass copying
14. Withholding of publication of examination results on ground of illegal admissions
15. Cancellation of examination results—Malpractice by student
16. Discrimination between private and Governmental institutions
17. Autonomy as regards determination of fee structure in private unaided professional colleges
18. Affiliation to schools
19. Right to Free Education is not an absolute right
20. Education and Reservation
21. Role of teachers
22. Pay of Teacher of Private Institution
23. Rights of management to appoint qualified persons
24. Erection of advertisement hoardings inside school premises—Deleterious effect on mental well-being of children
25. Right of institution for affiliation and imposing of conditions
26. Education—Granting interim relief by interim orders—Propriety of
27. School—Direction for shifting
28. Education—Whether ‘Service’ under the Consumer Protection Act
29. Education as a trade/occupation
30. Award of compensation/damages in public law action
RIGHT TO LINGUISTIC MINORITIES
31. Minority—Constitutional concept
32. Minority community—Identification of—To be on State basis
33. Additions to list of minorities—Conceding to claims by different sections of society—Would be sowing seeds of multinationalism in India
34. Right guaranteed to religious and linguistic minorities by Article 30 (1) and regulatory measures
35. Obligation of Courts to protect the rights of minorities
MINORITY INSTITUTIONS
36. Minority educational institution—Right conferred by Article 30
37. Minority Institution—Right to appoint teachers
38. Establishment of minority educational institutions
39. Welfare Scheme of State—Implementation of mid-day meal to children in minority institutions
40. Identification of minority educational institutions
41. Minority educational institution—Aid or recognition—Grant of
42. Minority institution—Admission policy
43. Fee structure—Capitation fee
44. Commercialisation of education—Charging of capitation fee by unaided minority educational institutions
45. Acquisition of property of Minority institution
HIGHER EDUCATION
46. No fundamental right to claim higher education
47. Residence requirements for admission in medical colleges
48. Region-wise classification for admission to Medical Colleges
49. Right of the students for admission in medical colleges
50. Lowering of minimum qualifying marks at the post-graduate level of medical education
51. Upgradation of existing Advance Diploma Course to B. Tech Course
52. Post Graduate students—Claim for stipend
LEGAL EDUCATION
53. Legal education and free legal aid
DISCIPLINE IN EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS
54. Role of Headmaster to maintain discipline
55. Stay in hostel after closure of University not proper
56. Allegation of use of unfair means in examination
POLITICAL INTERVENTION IN
EDUCATIONAL
INSTITUTIONS
57. Political intervention in educational institutions
58. Extra-curricular activities—An integral part of education
59. Political activities within the college campus
60. Students’ Union—Election of
61. Election of class representative in College
62. Right of teacher to vote and contest election
CHAPTER 25
Human Rights and Freedom of Religion
SECULARISM AND FREEDOM OF RELIGION
1. Secularism—A basic feature of the Constitution
2. Sources of concept of secularism
3. Secularism—Acquisition of Ram Janam Bhoomi/Babri Masjid—Not unsecular
4. Definition of Religion
5. Right to freedom of religion—Necessary component of the Constitution
6. Right to cure ailments through religious practices including "faith healing"—Cannot be claimed as fundamental right
7. States have leeway in regulation of religion
8. Management of temple—Is a secular act—Can be controlled by State
9. Essential practice of religion
10. Tolerance in practise of religion—Necessary for unity of the country
11. Right to worship
12. Freedom to manage religious affairs—Scope
13. Religious instructions
14. Study of religious philosophy and culture in educational institutions
15. Imparting of education and religions in educational institutions
16. Religious freedom—Use of loudspeakers
17. Singing of National Anthem vis a vis Fundamental Right
18. Religious opinion—Interference of Government
19. Secular nature of the Indian Constitution
20. Discrimination on ground of religion
21. Right of propagation of Religion
22. Right to superstitions—Protection under Article 26 (c) and (d)
23. Religion and marriage
RELIGIOUS DENOMINATIONS
24. Conditions to be satisfied by religious denomination
25. Administration of property by a religious denomination
26. Religion—‘Hinduism’—How different from ‘Jainism’
27. Ananda Marga—A religious denomination
28. Tandava dance by Ananda Margis in public streets—Whether a fundamental right
29. Ayodhya and communalism issues
30. Imposition of assessment on land held by a religious denomina-tional institution
31. Acquisition of land for samadhi for development purposes
32. Acquisition of religious place—Criteria for
33. Right of State to acquire property of religious denomination
34. Immunity from acquisition to a place of religious worship
35. Right to bury dead bodies
36. Shifting of grave—Directions of Court
37. Growing beard—Not an essential part of Islamic religion
CHAPTER 26
Human Rights and Inter-Caste and
Inter-Religion Marriages
1. Caste of a woman on marriage
2. Reservation—Effect of marriage/adoption
3. Reservation of seat for member of Scheduled Tribe
4. Right to marry
5. AIDS and duty of confidentiality
CHAPTER 27
Right of Cohabitation
1. Right to love and marry
2. Cohabitation—What is ?
3. Shift in tradition of marriage and fidelity
4. Right of Cohabitation
5. Cohabitation and criminal law
6. Cohabitation—Legal and personal problems
7. Cohabitation—As an alternative to marriage
8. Cohabitation and Hindu Law
9. Cohabitation and contract
10. Cohabitation—Increase of pregnancy and illegitimate births
CHAPTER 28
Right to Health and Medical Care
RIGHT TO HEALTH AND MEDICAL CARE
1. Right to life and jurisprudence of personhood
2. Provision of medical services and discharge of constitutional obligation
3. Access to medical treatment
4. Public health—Exploitation of patients
5. Professional obligations to save life and legal impediments
6. Health Insurance of workmen—A fundamental right
7. Medical treatment abroad
8. Manufacture of drugs and formulations injurious to health
Duties of doctor
9. Duties of doctor and discretion in choosing treatment
Negligence and malpractice
10. Negligence of doctor
11. Test of medical negligence
12. Error of judgment of doctor is not negligence
13. Compensation to consumer for injury suffered
14. American medical malpractice litigations
IMMUNITY OF DOCTOR
15. Immunity to medical practitioner for negligence
PATIENT AS CONSUMER
16. Patient is consumer when service hired for consideration
17. Beneficiary of service paid for, is a consumer
18. When complainant not a consumer
19. Complainant not a consumer in case of free medical treatment
20. Legal representative of deceased is a consumer
21. Locus standi of legal representative
COMPENSATION FOR DEFICIENCY IN SERVICE
22. Courts have an obligation to grant relief
23. Ampoule of injection—Not fit for human consumption—Complainant entitled to compensation
24. Compensation for negligence causing physical pain and mental anguish
25. Contaminated syrup—Compensation to complainant
26. Actionable negligence in prescribing wrong medicine
27. Default in supply by attendant—Liability for compensation
28. Sterilisation operation—Compensation upon failure of
29. Family planning programme—Decrees passed on failure of sterilization operations—Need for devising a welfare fund or insurance scheme
30. Performance of second operation without consent of complainant
31. By-pass surgery—Deficiency of service
32. Question of delay or negligence by doctor
33. Failure to prove negligence by doctor—Complaint dismissed
34. Operation—Negligence to be established
CHAPTER 29
Right to Smoke
1. General
2. Does one have the Fundamental Right to Smoke ?
3. Smoking—Its implications
4. Smoking—General effects of
5. Smoking and Pulmonary Diseases
6. Smoking—Effects on pregnant women
7. Smoking—Other health consequences
8. Passive Smoking (Environmental Smoke Exposure)
9. Court’s intervention to prevent public nuisance of smoking
10. Smoking in public places—Illegal and unconstitutional
11. Imposition of ban on sale of Bidi/Cigarettes on trains and plat-forms
CHAPTER 30
Rights of Persons suffering from AIDS
1. Introductory
2. AIDS—What is ?
3. AIDS—Causes of
4. Social reaction towards AIDS infected persons
5. Ethical issues emerging from AIDS
6. Protection of confidentiality of AIDS victim
7. Compelling a person to take HIV test
8. Right to dignity of AIDS person
9. Right to privacy
10. Conflict of individual rights and public rights
11. Isolation of AIDS infected persons—Constitutional validity
12. Denial of employment to AIDS infected persons
13. Right to marry
CHAPTER 31
Right to Profession and Trade
RIGHT TO PROFESSION, TRADE AND BUSINESS
1. Right to livelihood—A part of right to life
2. Freedom and right of profession
3. Rights can be claimed against State only
4. Reasonableness of restrictions
5. Taxation and restriction to trade
6. Restriction and prohibition
7. Municipality membership—Restrictions
8. Practising medicine without necessary certification or qualification
9. Right to carry on business inherently pernicious and dangerous to the society
10. Prohibition on slaughter of cows and calves—Expression "other milch and draught cattles"—Does not limit prohibition to period they remain functional— Expression has been used to describe a species and not with regard to age
11. Prohibition on slaughter of cow and her progeny—Does not amount to total ban on activity of Butchers—It is only a restriction on trade of Butchers
12. Trade creating pollution not allowed
13. Sale of food items in tetra packets and poly bags inside the zoo
14. Prohibition on sale of eggs within Municipal limits—Not an unreasonable restriction on right to trade
15. General insurance business
16. Non-renewal of licence of Rickshaw pullers
17. Acquisition of monopoly to trade by the State
RIGHTS OF HAWKERS
18. Right to carry on trade on street pavements
19. Right to hawk or squat
20. Right of hawker for street trading
21. Right to carry on business by squatting on pavements of public streets
22. Hawking may be prohibited near hospitals
23. Hardship of hawker if prevented from carrying on business
24. Rehabilitation of evicted hawkers—Formation of Policy
TOURISM AND HOTEL INDUSTRY
25. Rules, guidelines and Regulation framed by the Government for the tourism industry—Whether violative of the right to carry on such business
26. Running of Restaurant—Whether prevention thereof is an infringement
UNAUTHORISED AND ILLEGAL
CONSTRUCTIONS
ON ROADS
27. Limitation by Municipality
28. Preservation of public property
29. Unauthorised construction on public roads
30. Validity of constructions on pavements or roads
CHAPTER 32
Human Rights and Consumerism
1. Protection of consumer from exploitation
2. Aim of the Consumer Protection Act—Protection from exploitation
3. Role of voluntary organisations to educate consumers
4. Employees Provident Fund Scheme—Whether a ‘service’ under the Consumer Protection Act
5. Legal practitioners—Whether render ‘service’ under the Consumer Protection Act
6. Claim for continuous supply of electricity
7. Deficiency of service of supply of electricity
8. Levy of peak hour charges
9. Interest on refundable security
10. Compensation—Object of
11. Quantification of damages—Relevant factors
12. Safety of passenger in the railways
13. Medical treatment in private hospital
14. Deficiency in service—Medical negligence
15. Deficiency in service—Non-admission of patient on account of non-availability of bed
16. CAT Scan and free treatment
17. Leakage of underground water pipeline
18. Harassment and mental agony—Compensation for
19. Inconvenience and hardship—Compensation for
20. Loss of consignment—Compensation for
21. Mental pain and agony—Compensation for
22. Non-declaration of examination result—Compensation for
23. Deficiency of service—Non-delivery of car to purchaser despite the payment of money
24. Deficiency of service—Denial of boarding passes by airline to passengers with confirmed tickets
25. Refund of sale price
26. Deficiency of service—Theft of jewellery from Bank locker
27. Wrong disconnection of telephone
28. No entitlement for double accident benefit
29. Supply of drinking water in containers
30. Motor accident claim based on insurance policy—Claim for reimbursement—Can be adjudicated upon by Consumer Forum
31. Misrepresentation—Unfair trade practice
CHAPTER 33
Right to Advertise
1. General
2. Prohibition of advertisement—Test of reasonableness
3. ‘Compelled speech’ or ‘must carry provisions’ in advertisements
CHAPTER 34
Human Rights and Right to Move Freely
1. Right to move about freely.
2. Surveillance of persons.
3. Right to use of public roads for locomotion.
4. Regulation of traffic—Powers of Commissioner of Police to ‘regulate’.
5. Bundh—Meaning of.
6. "Bundh"—Entails restriction of free movement.
7. Bundh—Results in stoppage of transport system.
8. "Bundh"—No locomotion possible.
9. Calling of bundh by political party is a fundamental right.
10. Damage to public property during hartal—Recovery of compensation.
11. Exercise of freedom to form unions.
12. Right to travel abroad.
CHAPTER 35
Right to Passport and Travel Abroad
RIGHT TO PASSPORT
1. Passport—What is ?
2. Passport—Importance of.
3. Refusal to issue passport.
RIGHT TO TRAVEL ABROAD
4. Right to travel abroad.
5. Right to travel abroad—Impounding of passport.
6. Impounding of passport—Failure to appear before Court in pending criminal proceedings
CHAPTER 36
Right to Shelter
1. Right to Shelter—A Fundamental Right
2. Need for National Housing Policy
3. Shelter—National Rent Tribunal
4. Right to encroach
5. Removal of encroachment of pavement dwellers by Municipality—Principles of natural justice to be followed
6. Eviction of hutment dwellers from lands belonging to Port Trust
7. Right to shelter—Statutory tenancies
8. Problem of Slums
CHAPTER 37
Right to Privacy
1. Right to privacy—A basic right
2. Right to privacy in India
3. Right to privacy in Public Law
4. Right of Privacy—Scope of
5. Right to privacy—Not an absolute right
6. Police surveillance
7. Right to privacy vis-a-vis Freedom of Press
8. Right of privacy and doctor-patient relationship
9. Right of privacy—Sexual autonomy of women
10. Right to privacy—Use of contraceptives
11. Right to privacy vis a vis right of procreation
12. Right to privacy—Whether violated when parties directed to undergo medical test in suit for dissolution of marriage on grounds of non-consummation of marriage
13. Telephone tapping—Serious invasion to right of privacy
CHAPTER 38
Public Wrongs and Public Interest Litigation
1. Public policy
2. Public policy—Remedy of writ
3. Court’s interference in administrative matters
4. Judicial review and appeal—Difference between
5. Public wrong—Remedy of
6. Maintenance of secrecy
7. Public Interest Litigation—Meaning of
8. Public Interest Litigation—Evolution of
9. Public Interest Litigation—Principles of
10. Public Interest Litigation—Extent of jurisdiction
11. Public Interest Litigation—Conditions for maintainability
12. Public Interest Litigation—Locus standi of petitioner
13. Public Interest Litigation—Withdrawal of
14. Public Interest Litigation—Persons not authorised to use siren or red light on cars using them
15. Public Interest Litigation—Regulation of traffic due to general movement of VIPs
16. Public Interest Litigation—Use of sports stadium for conducting farmers’ conference
17. Public Interest Litigation—Property earmarked for park leased out for construction of temple
18. Public Interest Litigation—Management of temples
19. Public Interest Litigation—Burial of dead bodies in land reserved for public utility
20. Public Interest Litigation—Grant of national award for teachers
21. Public Interest Litigation—Allotment of land to school
22. National Anthem—Deletion of word ‘Sindh’ therefrom
23. Public Interest Litigation—Service matters
24. Freedom fighters—Pensionary benefit
CHAPTER 39
Human Rights and Citizenship
1. Citizen—Meaning of
2. Citizenship—Concept of
3. Foreign Company—Right of Citizenship under Article 19 of the Constitution
4. Nationality and Citizenship
5. Minor—Citizenship of
6. Persons subject to Army Act—Citizenship of
7. Domicile—Definition of
8. Nationality—Citizenship—Domicile
9. Citizenship/Domicile—Burden of Proof
10. Domicil—Principles for determination of
11. Domicile and Residence
12. Domicile of a child
13. 'Place of birth' and 'domicile'—Different concepts
14. Indian citizenship—Animus manendi essential
15. Determination of citizenship—Forum for
16. Freedom only for citizens
17. Foreigner refused citizenship—Writ not maintainable
18. Citizen of India voluntarily acquiring citizenship of Foreign Country—Order to quit India
CHAPTER 40
Human Rights of Foreigners
1. General
2. Fundamental rights when available to a foreigner
3. Equality in the treatment of foreigners
4. Commonwealth Citizenship—Status of.
5. Regulation of Movement of Foreigners in Indian Territory—Every house holder is duty bound to inform police about arrival or stay of foreigners in his house
6. Power to expel foreigners
7. Personal liberty—Deprivation—Does not take place in case of identification and deportation of foreigner
8. Accused, a Pakistani national staying in India without any document—Deportation of
9. Extension of stay by foreigner—Order of deportation
10. Admission to foreign students—Rational policy to be framed
11. Preventive detention of foreign national
12. Foreign national involved in criminal conspiracy
CHAPTER 41
Human Rights of Refugees
1. Historical tradition of India
2. Recognition of refugees
3. Reception and residence of alien—Discretionary with the State
4. Refugee—Interpretation of
5. Right to enjoy asylum
6. Refugees from Bangladesh—Acquisition of Citizenship
7. Protection of Refugees
8. Right of refugees to return to their country
9. Implementation of International Humanitarian Treaties and Conventions in India
10. Principle of non-refoulment
11. Principles for enforcement of Humanitarian Law
CHAPTER 42
Rights of Defence Personnel
1. Fundamental rights—Not extended to Armed Forces2. Necessity of restriction of Fundamental rights of members of Armed Forces
3. Provision of free legal service to officer facing trial before the Court Martial
4. Civilians employed by Armed Forces
5. Freedom of Association—Restriction for Armed Forces
6. Competency of State Legislature to enact
7. Induction into Armed Forces and religious belief against war
8. Freedom of Association—Restriction on P.A.C. and the P.A.C. Revolt case
CHAPTER 43
Human Rights and Communal Riots
1. General
2. Demolition of Babri Masjid and communal riots
3. Non-recovery of dead body or weapon of offence is not fatal
4. Compensation for losses in communal riots
CHAPTER 44
Human Rights in the Terrorised Areas
1. Terrorist act—Connotation of
2. Terrorism—Global menace of
3. Declaration of "disturbed area" and powers under the Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act, 1958
4. Armed Forces only to assist Civil Power of the State
5. Disturbed area—Scope to examine—Justiciability
6. Preventive detention to maintain internal security
7. Safeguards in use of Preventive Detention
8. Information about terrorist act to police—Any person can be compelled to give information
9. Martial law and suspension of Habeas corpus
10. Lack of evidence—Conviction illegal
11. Conviction by Designated Court on unreliable evidence—Liable to be set aside
12. Court’s power to close prosecution evidence
13. Confessional statement under Section 15 of TADA Act—Admissibility of, in a different case
14. Enhancement of sentence by Supreme Court—Legality of
15. Inference of conscious possession and knowledge about weapon and explosive
16. Recovery on the basis of disclosure statement
17. Necessity of sanction for other penal offences with TADA
18. Mens rea—An essential ingredient
19. Compensation for illegal detention
CHAPTER 45
Rights in Emergency
1. Proclamation of Emergency in England
2. Proclamation of Emergency in India
3. Suspension of Fundamental Rights
4. Emergency—Effect on the right under Article 32
5. Fundamental Rights—Where cannot be suspended
6. Suspension of Fundamental Rights during Emergency—44th Amendment of the Constitution—Effect of
7. Suspension of Fundamental Rights vis a vis suspension of their enforcement
8. Whether Presidential Order has to comply with Article 14
9. Duration of Emergency—Not justiciable
CHAPTER 46
Property and Easement Rights
PROPERTY RIGHTS
1. ‘Property’—Meaning of
2. Right to Property in England
3. "Property" in Constitution of India as originally enacted
4. Right to Property after the 44th Amendment
5. Right to Property—Now a Constitutional Right
6. Property—Right to use and enjoy
7. Building Regulations—Object is to regulate construction activities
8. Deprivation of property—Land acquisition by Government
9. Acquisition of right of user in land
10. Agrarian reform—Concept of
11. Deprivation of right of property without acquisition
12. Acquisition—Violation of
13. Acquisition of land—Public purpose
14. Land Acquisition—Compensation—Determination of Market value
15. Locus standi—Acquisition of land
16. Interest for non-payment of land acquisition compensation
17. Exemplary costs for non-payment of land acquisition compensation
18. Right of possession and actual possession—Distinction between
19. Assignment of land
20. Acquisition of assigned land—Compensation
21. Assigned land—Prohibition on transfers and alienation
22. Resumption of land
23. Provisions for seizure and confiscation under the Forest Act
24. Unlawful possession of property
25. Proceedings under Section 145, Cr. P.C. not to be used for settling issue of partition
26. Public nuisance and private nuisance
27. Remedies against nuisance
28. Public way—Encroachment on
29. Removal of blockage/obstruction on public road
30. Criminal trespass and causing damage to property
31. Power to alienate properties
32. Right to abandon the right conferred by law
33. Transfer of immovable property by Schedule Tribes
34. Transfer of minor’s property by legal guardian
35. Perspective right—Claim of
36. Renewal of lease—Right to
37. Grave-yards—Kinds of
38. Grave-yard—Presumption of
39. Customary Right over Burial ground
40. Infringement of right to form society
EASEMENT RIGHTS
41. Difference between licence and interest
42. Customary Rights and Public Rights—Distinction between
43. Easement and natural rights
44. Ownership and easement rights
45. Easement by prescription cannot be claimed in absence of necessary proof
46. Hostile claim on property and prescriptive acquisition
47. Prescriptive easement and easement by grant
48. Dispute concerning easementary rights
49. Easementary rights of fishing vis a vis public purpose
50. Easement or otherwise
51. Right of neighbour as natural right
52. Threat to lateral support
53. Injury of deprivation of right to be established
54. Quasi-easement rights
55. Right for beneficial enjoyment by owner
56. Permissive possession for beneficial enjoyment
57. Right of easement dependent upon owner’s permission
58. Right of way claimed by public
59. Right of way in uninterrupted use for 20 years
60. Right of way—Encroachment not justified
CHAPTER 47
Intellectual Property Rights
1. Intellectual property—Explained
2. Types of Intellectual Property
3. Intellectual Property right—A negative right
4. Rule of lex situs—Application of
5. Municipal law and International law—Variance in
6. Invention of new product—Explained
7. Legal monopoly of patent holder
8. Copyright—Protection of
9. Similarity of design—Infringement of Designs Act
10. Internet domain names—Entitled to protection as a trade mark
11. Bio-piracy and limitations of I.P.R
CHAPTER 48
Human Rights and Advocates
1. Legal profession—Its social dimensions
2. Right of Advocate to practise but no right to chamber
3. Right of advocate—Subject to restrictions
4. Enrolment of Priests or Nuns as advocates—Eligibility
5. Lawyers cannot solicit brief in any manner
6. Right of advocates to practise—Explained
7. Bar Council of India Rules, 1975, Rule 39—Enforceability of—Hearing of advocate
8. Advocates to maintain decorum of Courts
9. Contempt of Court by Advocates
10. Debarring Advocate from practising on committing contempt of Court
11. Right to practise as Mukhtar—Necessary requirements
12. Appointment of Public Prosecutors and renewal of their terms
13. Social obligations of members of the legal profession
14. Professional misconduct by Advocates—Citing overruled cases
15. Lien of Advocate over litigation files for his unpaid fees
16. Advocate as a litigant
17. Use of force or violence against members of the legal profession
18. Strike by lawyers
19. Professional misconduct
20. Representation of detenu through legal practitioner
21. Seating arrangements in Court-rooms
22. Right of litigant for seating accommodation
CHAPTER 49
Human Rights and Role of Police
1. Role of Police in democratic set up
2. Functioning of Police and Human Rights
3. External Pressures and Police Force
4. Injustice due to Latrogenic Police Process
5. Investigation by Police
6. Actions of police officers not to be approached with initial distrust
7. Police association—Restriction of rights
CHAPTER 50
Human Rights and Judiciary
1. Judiciary—The Guardian of the rule of law and temple of justice
2. Deep-rooted faith in impartiality of Judges
3. Function of a Judge
4. Judicial system—Conditions for efficient working
5. Judicial activism
6. Judicial hierarchy—Relationship between Supreme Court and High Courts
7. Functions of the Court
8. Powers of High Court under Article 226/227
9. Powers of High Court to do justice
10. Law of one State contrasting with Law of another State cannot be struck down
11. Judicial restraint
12. Rule of stare decisis
13. Precedents
14. Review of judgment
15. Judicial review
16. Restitution—Meaning and scope
17. Power of recalling orders
18. Principles of natural justice
19. Appellate Court not required to hear judicial functionary where orders are questioned—Natural Justice
20. Necessity of giving a reasoned order
21. Reasonableness of State action
22. Doctrine of legitimate expectation
23. Doctrines of promissory estoppel and legitimate expectation
24. Policy decision
25. Policy decision—Cannot be assailed on ground of mere denial of legitimate expectation
26. Necessity of giving reasons
27. Appointment of Judges—Not an executive act
28. Appointment of Judges of High Courts—Procedure
29. Appointment of Acting Chief Justice—Need for consultation
30. Acting Chief Justice—Entitlement to higher ceiling of pension
31. Woman as a Judge
32. Judicial Officers—Duties and expectations from
33. Judicial Officers—Should not indulge in fanciful litigations
34. Adequacy of strength of Judges
35. Transfer of case—Necessity of
36. Transfer of case—Requirements of
37. Transfer of case to another State—Considerations
38. Fair criticism of the Court
39. Imputation of bias of Judge
40. Making of disparaging remarks against lower Court—Expunction of
41. Right to scandalise the Judiciary
42. Contempt of Court
43. Contempt by Police Officer—Guidelines for proper sentence
44. Transfer policy of Judges
45. Compulsory retirement of Judges
46. Principles governing compulsory retirement
47. Post-retirement appointment of Judges
48. Appointment on Inquiry Commission of a retired Judge
49. Reference to three-Judge Bench
50. Judicial discipline
51. Interference of Court in writ jurisdiction
52. Interference by Apex Court under Articles 32 and 142 in Commissions of Enquiry Act, 1952, Section 8-B
53. Liberty of citizens
54. Adverse comments in judgments against persons who were not before the Court
55. Hearing of appeal—Powers of Appellate Court
56. Plight of a child to appear as witness
57. Witness—Permission to sit in Court proceedings
58. Protection of witnesses
59. Writ petition for compensation
CHAPTER 51
Human Rights and Role of Criminal Courts
1. Primary aims of Criminal Justice System
2. Objects of Criminal trial
3. Humanisation of Criminal Justice Administration
4. Administration of justice vis-a-vis fair trial
5. Cardinal principle in administration of criminal justice
6. Necessity of establishing corpus delicti
7. Apprehension of fair investigation
8. Pendency of cases in Criminal Courts—Reasons for
9. Judicial crusadism
10. Delay in trial of criminal cases—Remedial measures
11. Steps to control victimisation of women
12. Investigation of crimes against women
13. Stay of criminal case pending civil case
14. High Court’s jurisdiction to direct impleadment of a person as accused
15. Victim and the Criminal Justice System
16. Award of compensation by Criminal Courts
CHAPTER 52
Human Rights and Personal Liberty
1. Constitutional philosophy of personal liberty
2. Personal liberty and democracy
3. Right to life with dignity
4. Freedom of people and security of State
5. Protection of personal liberty under Article 21
6. Remedy under Article 21 available to non-citizens also
7. Provisions for safeguarding fundamental rights
8. Protection of the individual from oppression and abuse by the law enforcing officers
9. Personal liberty and preventive detention
10. Compelling a person to submit himself to blood test—Interference with right of personal liberty
11. Delay in registration of FIR—Compensation for
12. Illegal incarceration and compensation
13. Liability of Government for tortious act
14. Claim of compensation in Public law and Private law
15. Family pension and compensation—Award of
16. Insufficient proof of illegal detention—Not entitled for compensation
17. Accused involved in a number of cases—Deprivation of personal liberty
CHAPTER 53
Right to Silence
1. Protection against self-incrimination
2. Concept of inviolable right of silence in India
3. Right of silence in the English system
4. Right to remain silent during interrogation
5. Freedom of speech implies right to remain silent
6. Protection against testimonial compulsion under Article 20 (3)
7. Accusation of offence—Essential condition for application of Article 20 (3)
8. "Person accused of an offence"—Meaning of
9. Accused making statement voluntarily while in police custody
10. Incriminatory and compelled testimony—Difference between
CHAPTER 54
Right to Legal Aid
1. Access to justice
2. Right to legal aid
3. The right of choice of lawyer for legal defence
4. Accused to be informed of his right for free legal aid
5. Banning prescriptions for free legal aid to prisoners
6. Payment of fees to a lawyer for free legal service
7. Right to standard legal education
8. Balancing of right to legal aid with social justice
CHAPTER 55
Right to Speedy Trial
1. Purpose of Criminal Justice
2. Fundamental right of speedy trial
3. Justice delayed is justice denied
4. Delay in speedy trial causes mental anguish
5. Inordinate delay in trial—Violative Article of 21 of the Constitution
6. Suspended animation without cause for a long period—Effect of
7. Delay in trial—Entitlement of accused to bail
8. Delay in trial of undertrial prisoners
9. Delay in trial of corruption cases
10. Delay in trial and mounting arrears of cases
11. Delay in trial due to lawyers’ strike
12. Delay in execution of death sentence
13. Judicial compassion and compensation for mental agony
CHAPTER 56
Handcuffing
1. "Handcuffing"—Meaning of
2. Minimum freedom of movement cannot be denied
3. To fetter prisoners in iron is inhuman
4. Guidelines for use of handcuffs by Police
5. Handcuffing of prisoners—Approval of Court to be obtained
6. Handcuffing between prison and Court—Necessity of judicial approval
7. Handcuffing of social worker—Violative of Article 21 of the Constitution
8. Handcuffing of Chief Judicial Magistrate
9. Handcuffing of under-trials
10. Compensation to victim for handcuffing
CHAPTER 57
Arrest and Detention
1. Arrest—Meaning of
2. Purpose and intent of preventive detention
3. Preventive detention—Serious invasion of personal liberty
4. Preventive detention—Order quashing detention reversed—Whether detenue to serve remainder period
5. Constitutional safeguards against unfair arrest
6. Arrest on credible information
7. Prompt investigation after arrest
8. Arrest by Head Constable
9. Arrest on requisition from another police station—Identity and reason to be disclosed
10. Arrest—Validity of
11. Arrest by police officer without warrant
12. Credible information—Connotation of
13. Arrest of deserter from the armed forces
14. Person involved in crime liable for arrest anywhere in India
15. Arrest of person only for cognizable offence
16. Person in possession of house-breaking implement
17. Police Officer—Who is?—
18. Proclaimed offender—Arrest of
19. Reasonable complaint—Action on
20. Reasonable suspicion necessary for arrest
21. Inherent right of arrested person
22. Validity of arrest without warrant
23. Procedure of arrest by the police officer
24. Difference between Section 54 (41 new) and Section 56 (55 new), Cr. P.C
25. Apprehension
26. Police officer authorised to arrest a person without warrant
27. Arrest and preventive detention
28. Detention in jail of arrested person
29. Unlawful arrest
30. Sections 56 and 57, Cr. P.C.—Object of
31. Pre-trial custody
32. Delay in investigation
33. History-sheets and Surveillance Register
34. Arrest can be made by authorised officer, though not a police officer
35. Power of Civil SDO for detention
36. Inhibition of sending a child to jail
37. Preventive detention and imprisonment—Difference between
38. Interference by Court at pre-execution stage of the order of preventive detention
39. Detention order—Satisfaction of detaining authority
40. Right of detenu to make representation
41. Successive representations by detenu
42. Preventive detention—Delay in forwarding representation
43. Exercise of power by Government to revoke detention order on representation made by detenu
44. Preventive detention—Challenge to
45. Observance of Section 50, Cr. P.C.—Mandatory—
46. Monetary compensation and exemplary cost in mischievous arrest
47. Release of arrested person
48. Denial of benefit to juvenile offenders is an exception
CHAPTER 58
Search and Seizure
1. Necessity and usefulness of search during investigation
2. Issue of search warrant without preliminary inquiry—Legality of
3. Kinds of searches
4. General search or inspection
5. Compliance with Section 165, Cr. P.C.—Mandatory
6. Search warrant—Whether violative of Article 19 (1) (f) of the Constitution
7. Scope and object of Section 100, Cr. P.C.
8. Applicability of Section 100, Cr.. P.C. to searches under other Acts
9. Power to issue search-warrant under other Acts
10. Search under the N.D.P.S. Act
11. Conditions for issue of search-warrant
12. Order of a search-warrant—Application of mind
13. Recording of reasons—Necessity of
14. Recording of grounds of belief
15. Search in exigent circumstances
16. Search warrant—Irregularity in
17. Issue of search-warrant against an accused
18. Place used for deposit or sale of stolen property
19. Description of the property and place to be searched in the search warrant
20. To whom the search warrant can be issued
21. Conduct of search by superior officer
22. Search made outside the limits of police station—Requirements of
23. Necessity of presence of occupant during search
24. Necessity of presence of search witnesses
25. Independent and respectable witnesses—Meaning of
26. "Locality"—Meaning of
27. Presence of unauthorised persons during search
28. Refusal to attend search
29. Search of the searching party
30. Search without warrant
31. Inmate may refuse ingress if provisions of search are ignored
32. Resistance to illegal search
33. Resistance to search for a thing only
34. Obstruction to search officer executing search warrant
35. Searches at night
36. Control of the Magistrate over searches
37. Panchanama—Purpose of
38. Manner of preparation of search lists
39. Search list to be signed by witnesses
40. Copy of list of seized articles to be given to the occupant of the house
41. Panchanama—Signature of the accused
42. Non-supply of copy of panchnama to the accused—Effect on the trial
43. Sealing of seized property
44. Copies of record to be sent to Magistrate
45. Search—Oral evidence
46. Attendance of search witnesses in Court
47. Testimony of public servants
47. Effect of irregularities in search
48. Writ of mandamus for the return of seized articles
49. Section 100, Cr. P.C. and Section 27, Evidence Act are not analogous
50. Search of person—Manner of
51. Search in non-cognizable cases
52. Seizure of property during pendency before Court
53. Illegal search and seizure—Quashing of proceedings
CHAPTER 59
Bail and Remand
INTRODUCTION
1. Information of grounds of arrest and right to bail
2. No bail without arrest or appearance
3. Principles for bail
4. Reasons to be given in order granting bail
5. Grant of bail
BAIL BY POLICE
6. Bailable offence—Grant of bail
7. Can the police take bond for appearance before it ?
8. Right to bail in bailable offence not to be defeated by executive instructions
9. Bailable offence and non-bailable offence—Difference between
10. Offence initially bailable but subsequently turning out to be non-bailable
11. Bail granted by police—Magistrate cannot ask for fresh bail bond
BAIL BY MAGISTRATE
12. Object of Sections 167 and 309, Cr. P.C.
13. Applicability of Section 167, Cr. P.C.
14. Detention in police custody
15. Effect of detention in contravention of Section 167, Cr. P.C.
16. Limit of 15 days detention in police custody for single case
17. Grant of police custody after expiry of first fifteen days—Not permissible
18. Formal application for remand to police custody—Not necessary
19. Judicial function and proceedings
20. No order for detention in custody without evidence of guilt
21. No order for remand in absence of the accused
22. No remand to the custody of police
23. Police custody of an accused arrested after cognizance taken
24. Detention under Proviso (a) to Section 167 (2), Cr. P.C.
25. Procedure after police custody of 15 days
26. Period of investigation of a summons case
27. Period of limitation
28. Bail during detention before the expiry of period of 90/60 days
29. Period of 90/60 days—Computation of
30. Exclusion of public holiday
31. Temporary release for a few days—Exclusion of
32. Principles governing bail
33. Interim bail
34. Interim bail during pendency of bail application
35. Law regarding disposal of bail application
36. Power of Magistrate to grant bail—Limitations
37. Offences punishable with life imprisonment or for 10 years’ imprisonment
38. Conditions for bail under Section 436, Cr. P.C.
39. Formal application for remand by police
40. Bail under Proviso (a) to Section 167 (2), Cr. P.C.
41. Proviso (a) to Section 167 (2), Cr. P.C.—Mandatory
42. Rejection of bail application of co-accused
43. Bail on the basis of parity
44. Personal liberty and bail on same day
45. Right to get bail application expeditiously decided if possible on same day under Article 21 of the Constitution
46. Magistrate cannot postpone release to enable police to submit charge-sheet
47. Release on bail and further order of remand
48. Necessity of formal application by accused for bail
49. Detention not ipso facto illegal
50. Bail order on default
51. Prior illegal detention and right of bail
52. Right of compulsive bail—Relevant date in consideration for
53. Disposal of bail application on date of surrender
54. Cancellation of bail granted under Proviso (a) to Section 167 (2), Cr. P.C.
BAIL BY SESSIONS JUDGE
55. Grant of bail during investigation—Powers of Sessions Judge
56. Serious offences—Grant of bail is discretionary
57. Simultaneous bail application before Sessions Judge and the High Court
58. Bail refused by High Court—No power of Sessions Judge to grant bail on same facts
59. Power of Additional Sessions Judge or Assistant Sessions Judge to grant bail under Section 439, Cr. P.C.
60. Bail of under-trial prisoners—Grant of
61. Accused charged with gruesome murder—Bail not to be granted
62. Transfer of case by Sessions Judge to Additional Sessions Judge for trial—Power of Sessions Judge to grant bail
63. Cancellation of bail—Powers
BAIL BY HIGH COURT
64. Inherent power of High Court to grant bail
65. Extent of power of High Court to grant bail
66. Concurrent jurisdiction of Sessions Court and High Court—Whether Sessions Court to be moved first ?
67. Simultaneous bail application before the Sessions Judge and High Court
68. Delay in trial—Grant of bail by High Court
69. Successive bail applications
70. Withdrawal of bail petition filed in High Court—Effect of
71. Bail application rejected by High Court—Power of Additional Sessions Judge to grant bail on subsequent bail application on same facts
72. Bail by Appellate Court during pendency of appeal—Factors to be considered
73. Revisional power of High Court and bail
74. Improper cancellation of bail by Sessions Judge—Interference of High Court
75. Cancellation of bail by High Court granted under Section 389 (1), Cr. P.C.
BAIL BY SUPREME COURT
76. Power of Supreme Court to revise order of High Court granting or cancelling bail
77. Appeal before Supreme Court and grant of bail
78. Grant or refusal of bail by High Court or other Court—Interference by Supreme Court
ANTICIPATORY BAIL
79. Anticipatory bail vis a vis ordinary bail
80. Court’s power to grant anticipatory bail unfettered
81. Special case if to be made out
82. Anticipatory bail not to be granted on mere asking
83. Grant or refusal of anticipatory bail—Relevant considerations
84. Blanket anticipatory bail
85. Grant of anticipatory bail without lodging of F.I.R.
86. Anticipatory bail after issue of process
87. Anticipatory bail only in non-bailable offence
88. Second application for grant of anticipatory bail
89. Earlier application not pressed—Maintainability of subsequent application for anticipatory bail
90. Anticipatory bail—Duration of
91. Co-accused granted bail—Whether ground for granting anticipatory bail
92. Cancellation of anticipatory bail
93. Cancellation of bail
94. Cancellation of bail vis a vis rejection of bail application
95. Cancellation of bail in a bailable offence
96. Power of Magistrate to cancel bail in non-bailable offence
97. Cancellation of bail—Powers to be exercised with care and circumspection
98. Absence on medical ground—Bail should not be cancelled
99. Release on bail under proviso to Section 167 (2), Cr. P.C.—When such bail can be cancelled
100. Offence turning to be more serious subsequent to grant of bail
101. Bail order passed without jurisdiction—Cancellation of
102. Bail granted by the Superior Court—Whether could be cancelled by Magistrate?—
103. Bail granted by High Court—Sessions Judge has no power to cancel it
104. Transfer of bail application by Court of Session to Additional Sessions Judge or Assistant Sessions Judge—Propriety of
105. Cancellation of bail—Considerations for
106. Material considerations for cancellation of bail
107. Grant of bail—Wrong exercise of jurisdiction
108. Grant of bail by Sessions Judge—Cancellation by High Court
109. Power of High Court to cancel bail granted by it
110. Bail granted by a Judge of High Court—Not to be cancelled by another Judge on the same materials
111. Cancellation of bail on invalid grounds
112. Abuse of privilege of bail—Ground for cancellation
113. Offence converted into non-bailable offence from bailable offence—Re-arrest of accused without cancellation of bail—Improper
114. Cancellation of bail by Magistrate—High Court approached straight against such order
115. Cancellation of bail on fresh materials
116. Cancellation of bail of accused police officers
117. Who can apply for cancellation of bail ?—
AMOUNT OF BAIL
118. Amount of bail not to be excessive
119. Asking for cash security—When becomes harsh and illegal
120. Sufficiency of amount of bail—Judicial discretion of the Court
NEED FOR REFORM OF THE PRESENT BAIL SYSTEM
121. Present system of bail—Source of great hardship to the poor
122. Need for reform
123. Provisions of Anticipatory Bail do not apply in the State of Uttar Pradesh and the Author’s submission
CHAPTER 60
Human Rights and Torture in Police Custody
1. General2. Torture synonymous with darker side of human civilisation
3. Prohibition of torture lacks constitutional authority
4. Torture means both physical and mental pain or suffering—
5. Custodial torture—Assault on human dignity
6. Torture by police in custody
7. Torture in custody causing death—A murderous act
8. Protection of people from excesses of the State
9. Use of third degree methods in custody
10. Use of third degree methods by police—Prohibition of
11. Custodial violence and abuse of police powers
12. Methods of torture
13. Police torture disastrous to human rights awareness
14. Mental agony in police station
15. Arrest of women by police and violation of modesty
16. Blinding of undertrials by police
17. Physical mutilation in police custody
18. Lack of ocular evidence in cases of police torture or custodial death—Effect of
19. Injury caused by police—Presumption under Section 114-B, Evidence Act
20. Compensation—Appropriate and effective remedy for redressal
21. Compensation as a public law remedy
22. Custodial violence—Preventive measures
Chapter 61
Custodial Deaths
1. Custodial death—Worst kind of crime in a civilised society
2. Death in police custody—Entitled for monetary compensation under Articles 32 and 226 of the Constitution of India
3. Immunity of State in cases of custodial deaths
4. Police atrocities and compensation by Apex Court
5. Monetary compensation for infringement of fundamental rights
6. Death in police custody and compensation
7. Death in police custody—Manipulation of Police Records deprecated
8. Torture and death in other departments apart from police—Liable for compensation
9. Grant of Anticipatory Bail to Police Officer responsible for custodial death
10. Compliance of non-bailable warrant against police personnel in case of custodial death
11. Custodial death and compensation
CHAPTER 62
Police Encounters
1. Police encounters—Legality of
2. Police encounters—Petitions against
3. Fake encounters by police and compensation
CHAPTER 63
Rights of Accused Persons
1. "Accused"—Who is ?
2. Right of accused not to be convicted of an offence unless established by proof beyond reasonable doubt
Protection in respect of
conviction for
offences
3. Ex post facto laws and retrospectively
RIGHT TO BE INFORMED OF THE
GROUNDS IMMEDIATELY
AFTER THE ARREST
4. Communication of grounds of arrest—A constitutional safeguard
5. Warrant of arrest—Substance to be informed
RIGHT OF THE ARRESTED PERSON
for medical
examination
6. Medical examination of the accused
7. Arrested person has right of medical examination
right to be produced before a
magistrate within
24 hours of his arrest
8. Detention of an accused
9. Exclusion of the time taken in journey from place of arrest to the Court
10. Validity of detention order
11. Escape of accused detained beyond 24 hours—No offence
12. Accused not produced within 24 hours and recording of confession
RIGHT TO CONSULT A LAWYER OF HIS OWN CHOICE
13. Access of accused to legal adviser
14. Free legal assistance to accused
15. Right to be defended by a pleader
16. Right to have a counsel applies in appeals
17. Right to have counsel of his choice
18. When accused unrepresented—Duty of court
19. Counsel for indigent accused
20. Cases not covered by Section 304—Non-supply of pleader
21. Indigent accused—Right to be defended at State expenses
22. When consent repudiated by the accused
23. Counsel appointed not furnished with brief
24. Accused ill and unrepresented
25. Defence counsel not supplied with papers
26. Counsel for accused ill—Case to be adjourned
27. Representation in Juvenile Court
28. Right to be defended before Courts where lawyers not allowed to appear
29. Power-of-attorney-holder—No independent right to appear without permission of Court
30. Opportunity of cross-examination to counsel of accused
RIGHT TO BE TRIED BY AN
INDEPENDENT AND
IMPARTIAL JUDICIARY
31. Free and fair trial
32. Opportunity to the accused to have the case tried by another Court
33. No right to the accused to have a Magistrate of his choice
34. Committal proceedings
35. "Personally interested"—Meaning of
36. Disqualification on ground of pecuniary interest
37. Other interest or prejudice
38. Personal interest—Cases of
39. Cases in which there is no personal interest
40. Hearing of appeals
41. Visit to the place of occurrence
42. When the court is party to the proceedings
43. "Taking cognizance" and "trying the case" or "committing the case for trial"—Distinction between
44. Courts to be open to all
45. Presence of public at the place of trial
46. Criminal trial in camera—Invalid
47. In camera trial in rape case
INVESTIGATION AND CHARGE-SHEET
48. Report to be sent soon after completion of investigation
49. Magistrate’s order under Section 173, Cr. P.C.—Whether judicial
50. Power of Magistrate to accept relevant documents
51. Power of Magistrate to take cognizance of the offence
52. Withdrawal of case
53. Taking of cognizance—A judicial act
54. Magistrate not justified in taking cognizance on incomplete police report
55. Reopening of case—When not permissible
56. Charge-sheet—Not a complete thesis of the prosecution case
57. Final report of police—Use of
58. Additional charge-sheet—Filing of
59. Filing of report of Central Forensic Science Laboratory after submission of charge-sheet
60. Court’s direction for further investigation
61. Filing of piecemeal charge-sheet—Not legally permissible
62. Submission of charge-sheet by Sub-Inspector—No illegality
63. Charge-sheet—When deemed to be submitted
64. Cognizance on complaint of authorised officer
65. Further investigation after charge-sheet submitted and cognizance taken
66. Second complaint
67. No illegality in further investigation by another investigating agency
68. Further investigation by police after submission of final report under Section 169, Cr. P.C.
69. Further investigation on fresh material—Whether notice to accused necessary
70. Interference in investigation by State—Legality of
71. Charge-sheet when not to be filed by investigation agency
72. Reopening of investigation
73. Submission of report—Further investigation not precluded
74. Superior police officer can order for submission of fresh charge-sheet
75. Cancellation or closure of case—Opportunity of hearing to complainant
76. Quashing of F.I.RAfter filing of charge-sheet
RIGHT TO GET COPIES OF THE
DOCUMENTS AND STATEMENTS OF
WITNESSES ON WHICH THE PROSECUTION RELIES
77. Scope and applicability of Section 207, Cr. P.C.
78. Statements of witnesses—Copy to be supplied whether they are to be relied upon or not
79. Effect of failure to supply papers
80. Inquiry in cases triable by Sessions Court—Connotation of
81. Sessions Judge to order for supply of papers
82. Supply of copies in the Magistrate’s Court
83. "At the commencement of the trial"—Significance of
84. Magistrate’s order on police report—Whether judicial
85. Examination of records—Power of High Court
86. Second report of Chemical Examiner
87. Irregularity in trial
RIGHT TO HAVE DUE NOTICE OF THE CHARGES
88. Framing of charges
89. Perusal of case diary while framing charges
90. Framing of charge—Depriving accused to produce material evidence
91. Charge of offence vis a vis material on record
92. Critical appreciation of evidence at the stage of framing of charge—Not permissible
93. Framing of charge—Necessity of recording reasons for
94. Offence triable by Magistrate
95. Common charges—Framing of
96. Non-framing of separate charge
97. Framing of charge—Petition against
98. "Same offence"—Meaning of
99. Distinct offence
100. When offence is made of parts and every part is an offence they are not distinct
101. Acts constituting offence—When not distinct
102. Distinct offences
103. Distinct offences—Examples of
104. Separate order and trial for every distinct offence
105. Alteration of charge
106. Cancellation of charge and acquittal
107. Joint charge—Framing of
108. Joint trial and joinder of charges
109. Refusal to consolidate charges and hold joint trial
110. Separate trials where joint trial permissible—Legality of
111. Sale of adulterated goods—Joint trial of warranter and vendor
112. Joint trial—Proper procedure
113. Amalgamation of a case on police report and of a complaint case
114. Amalgamation of cases
115. Cross-case—Method of trial
116. Charge to be read and explained to the accused
117. After framing of charges—No power to drop proceedings
118. Committal of case to Sessions
119. Charges for murderous attack
120. Cases not exclusively triable by the Court of Session
121. When cases committed under Section 323 or 306 (5), Cr. P.C
122. Power under Section 319 (1), Cr. P.C. for enquiry
123. Power of Magistrate for recommittal of case
124. Procedure of trial before Chief Judicial Magistrate
125. Transfer of cases—Legality of
126. Acquittal in one charge does not necessarily lead to acquittal for another charge
RIGHT TO INSIST THAT EVIDENCE
BE RECORDED IN PRESENCE OF
THE ACCUSED EXCEPT IN SOME SPECIAL CIRCUMSTANCES
127. Evidence shall be taken in the presence of the accused or counsel
128. Examination of witness in the absence of accused and his counsel vitiates the trial
129. Name and description of witnesses—Part of evidence
130. Evidence of one cross-case cannot be used in other cases
RIGHT OF ACCUSED FOR EXEMPTION
OF PERSONAL
ATTENDANCE
131. Dispensing with personal attendance of accused
132. Grounds for exemption of personal appearance
133. Grant of exemption from personal attendance discretionary with the Magistrate
134. Personal attendance when not necessary
135. Exemption from personal appearance and status of the accused
136. The accused must be represented by a pleader
137. Vakalatnama not needed for exemption
138. Pardanashin woman entitled for exemption
139. Exemption from personal attendance—Legality of
140. Provisions of exemption do not apply to appeals
RIGHT TO TEST THE EVIDENCE BY
CROSS-
EXAMINATION
141. Cross-examination—Purpose of
142. Order of examination of witnesses
143. Right of cross-examination to adverse party
144. Party seeking cross-examination must be shown to be an adverse party
145. Court must actively participate in the trial
146. Cross-examination cannot be confined to matters testified in examination-in-chief
147. Opportunity of rebuttal not to be refused
148. Tendering a witness for cross-examination only
RIGHT TO PRODUCE DEFENCE WITNESSES
149. Defence of the accused
150. Witnesses of the accused—When to be summoned
151. Witnesses to be summoned for cross-examination
152. Refusal of accused to lead defence
153. Cost to be deposited before summoning witnesses
154. Duty of a court, when accused unrepresented and refuses legal aid
155. Right of prosecution to examine witnesses after the accused enters upon his defence
156. Reasonable opportunity to be given to the accused to produce documents
157. Right of the accused to summon papers at any stage under Section 91, Cr. P.C.
158. Summoning of defence witness
159. Production of documents by the prosecution after the close of prosecution case
160. Value of the written statement
161. Written statement by the accused and filing of documents
RIGHT NOT TO BE A WITNESS AGAINST HIMSELF
162. Testimonial compulsion and right against self-incrimination
163. Right not to be a witness against himself
164. Presence of counsel during interrogation
RIGHT TO HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY
FOR EXPLAINING THE
CIRCUMSTANCES APPEARING IN EVIDENCE
AGAINST AT THE TRIAL
165. Stage of examination of the accused
166. Applicability of Section 313, Cr. P.C
167. Object of Section 313, Cr. P.C
168. Manner of examination
169. Circumstances to be put to the accused
170. Examination of the accused
171. Personal examination of the accused
172. Not necessary to place each and every evidence
173. Attention of accused not drawn to every inculpatory material for his explanation—Effect
174. Delay in recording of victim’s statement
175. Accused to be questioned only about circumstances
176. Charges not framed in prescribed form
177. Provisions of Section 313, Cr. P.C. mandatory
178. Questioning of accused regarding circumstances
179. Circumstances must be put to the accused
180. Documents produced must be put to the accused
181. Re-examination of accused after deposition of witness under Section 540 of old Cr. P.C.
182. Examination by the appellate Court in case of omission
183. Examination of a deaf and dumb accused
184. "Question him generally"
185. Questions prepared in English—Not irregular
186. Putting many facts in one question—Defective method
187. Questions about bad character of accused
188. Questions about previous conviction—Not permissible
189. Statement to be recorded in detail
190. Record of police not required to be put to accused
191. Statement about plea of self-defence
192. Examination of accused—Cannot substitute evidence
193. Vague questions—Explanation regarding
194. Written statement of accused
195. Failure to mention a fact
196. Refusal of accused to answer
197. Evasive replies by accused
198. No incriminating circumstances—Accused not to be examined
199. Accused not to be cross-examined
200. Retrial after re-examination—Improper
201. Complete statement of accused to be considered
202. Statement not to be used against another co-accused
203. Prejudice due to non-examination or defective examination
204. Inculpatory material not indicated to the accused
205. Objection of non-compliance when can be taken by the accused
206. Accused must prove the prejudice caused
207. Question of prejudice cannot be raised in appeal
208. Confession of crime in the statement under Section 313, Cr. P.C
209. Examination where accused makes a confession
210. Use of the confession of a co-accused
211. Offence
212. Trial cannot be vitiated by error under Section 342, Cr. P.C. (new Section 313)
213. Want of territorial jurisdiction
214. Conviction
215. Evasive replies to be read against the accused
216. Non-examination of the accused—Objection by the complainant
RIGHT TO BE HEARD ABOUT THE
SENTENCE UPON
CONVICTION
217. Sentence to be passed on conviction
218. Separate sentence for separate conviction
219. Sentence to be passed only after hearing the accused
220. Hearing of accused obligatory at the sentencing stage
221. Hearing of accused on the question of sentence
222. Proper opportunity to accused and prosecution
223. Opportunity of hearing on sentence not given—Effect of
224. Hearing accused before sentencing is a fundamental requirement
225. Non-compliance of mandatory provisions is fatal to conviction
226. No adjournment to show cause against the sentence
227. Judgment to be delivered by same Judge who records the evidence
228. Conviction and order of sentence on same day—Against law
229. Acquittal only after following complete procedure
230. Proper acquittal order
231. Want of finding of acquittal or conviction on a charge amounts to acquittal
232. No order of discharge after framing of charge
233. Discharge order—Conditions of
PROTECTION AGAINST "DOUBLE JEOPARDY"
234. Double Jeopardy
235. Article 20 (2) of the Constitution and Section 300, Cr. P.C.—Distinction between
236. Double Jeopardy
237. Rule against double jeopardy
238. "Issue estoppel" and "autrefois acquit"—Distinction between
239. Plea of autrefois acquit —When could be raised
240. Double punishment—Prohibition of
241. Section 403, Cr. P.C.—When attracted
242. Rule of issue estoppel and res judicata
243. Binding nature of an earlier finding
244. Binding effect of finding of Criminal Courts in quasi-judicial proceedings
245. Offences committed in separate and independent transactions
246. No subsequent trial for the same offence
247. Many distinct offences committed in the same transaction
248. Subsequent trial for a distinct offence under Section 300 (2), Cr. P.C.—Consent of the State Government necessary
249. Subsequent trial for same facts when the first Court was incompetent to try the offence
250. Barring of subsequent trial—Conditions for
251. Bar of second trial—Requirements
252. Detention for arrears of land revenue
253. Applicability of Section 300, Cr. P.C
254. Trial for major offence when barred by trial for minor offence
255. Retrial for same offence barred till conviction or acquittal remains in force
256. Second trial while conviction or acquittal in force
257. Appeal—Jurisdiction of High Court
258. Acquittal or conviction of an accused—No bar for trial of another accused
259. Continuing offence—Bar of second trial
260. Cases not amounting to acquittal—No bar for fresh trial
261. Case dismissed due to misjoinder of charges—Does not amount to acquittal
262. Act or omission constituting offence under two or more enactments
263. Same act constituting offence under more than one enactment
264. Stopping of proceeding under Section 249 (old) of Cr. P.C.
265. Restoration of case dismissed in default
266. Cognizance of second complaint
267. Second complaint by proper person or authority
268. Withdrawal by one complainant—Subsequent trial for other offences
269. Where proceedings are void ab initio
270. Withdrawal of a complaint in summons case
271. Withdrawal from prosecution—No bar to second trial
272. Wrong name in complaint—Second complaint with correct name not barred
273. Compounding of offences in a compoundable case
274. Consequences happening afterwards making the offence graver
275. Acquittal in case of invalidity of sanction
276. All accused to be tried jointly
277. Order approving final report—No bar for second trial
278. Magistrate not empowered to review or recall his judicial order
279. Order of dismissal of complaint not set aside—Second complaint can be entertained
280. Prohibition of subsequent trial for same offence under Section 300 (403 old) of Cr. P.C
281. Lack of local jurisdiction
RIGHT TO GET COPY OF THE
JUDGMENT WHEN SENTENCED
TO IMPRISONMENT
282. "Copy of judgment"—Entitlement to get free on ground of poverty
283. Copies of depositions of witnesses and other parts of the record
284. Right to obtain copy—Whether personal appearance in Court necessary
285. Entitlement of third person to copies of judgments, etc
286. No stamp in appeal on copy of judgment supplied free of cost to the accused
RIGHT TO APPEAL IN CASE OF CONVICTION
287. Forums for appeal(a) Appeal to Supreme Court
(a) Appeal to Supreme Court
(b) Appeal to High Court
(c) Appeal to the Court of Session Judge
(d) Court of Session only can receive appeals
288. Appeal—Locus standi
289. When sentences not appealable—
290. Powers of High Court in appeal against acquittal
291. Appeal against acquittal—Powers of Court
292. Appellate Court to consider all grounds in appeal
293. Right of appeal accrues on conviction
294. Appeal against acquittal
295. Appeal against acquittal—Two views possible
296. Appeal against conviction—Principles for exercise of power by Supreme Court
297. Appeal against conviction—Accused acquitted of charges—Acquittal of co-accused though no appeal preferred by him
298. High Court has powers to take fresh evidence
299. When appeal does not lie to High Court
300. High Court cannot for the first time go into alternate charge
301. Combination of sentences and decision regarding appropriate forum of appeal
302. Appeal against conviction and sentence by third party—Legality of
303. Dismissal of criminal appeal in default—Not proper
304. Condonation of delay in appeal should be dealt with liberally
305. Enhancement of sentence sought by State—Appeal must be filed
306. Setting aside of conviction by High Court on minor discrepancies—Not proper
307. Revision against acquittal—Right of appeal to Supreme Court
RIGHT NOT TO BE IMPRISONED UPON
CONVICTION IN
CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES
308. Applicability of provisions of Section 360, Cr. P.C.
309. Benefit of probation for punishment under any law available
310. Probation of Offenders Act vis a vis Section 360, Cr. P.C.
311. Probation for offences punishable with fine
312. Grant of benefit of Section 360, Cr. P.C. cannot be refused
313. Provisions of Section 361, Cr. P.C. mandatory
314. Provisions of Section 361, Cr. P.C. when not applicable
315. Benefit of Section 360, Cr. P.C. in case of crimes against women
316. Accused to bring favourable circumstances on record
317. Considerations for extending the benefit of release on probation
318. Conviction under Section 379, I.P.C.
319. Release on bond
320. Probation only when no previous conviction proved
321. Release on probation—When cannot be claimed
322. Benefit of probation where offence not punishable with death or imprisonment for life
323. "To keep the peace and be of good behaviour"—Implies different concepts
324. Granting of probation is a discretionary power with the Court
325. Benefit of probation
326. Probation to be granted after conviction but before sentence
327. Granting probation—Grounds for
328. Previous conviction debars benefit of probation
329. Probation to first offender
330. Crucial date for reckoning the age of 21 years
331. Regard to age, character, antecedents etc. in grant of admonition
332. Admonition to be granted for trivial offence only
333. Rash and negligent driving, killing eight persons—Not entitled to benefit of Probation of Offenders Act
334. Appellate Court or revisional Court may release on probation or admonition
335. No appeal against order of probation or admonition by Government
336. Order for probation or admonition—Accused has right of appeal
337. Offences punishable for not more than two years’ imprisonment—Can be dealt with under Section 360 (3), Cr. P.C
CHAPTER 64
Punishment for Crime
1. Punishment for crime
2. Aims and objects of punishment
3. Considerations in sentencing policy
4. Proportionality between crime and punishment
5. Effect of sentence on social order
6. Rival theories of punishment
7. ‘Reparation’—Meaning of
8. Death sentence
9. Death sentence—Invocation of Article 21
10. Combination of sentence of death with fine—Legality of
11. Power of clemency
12. Remission of sentence
13. Claim of set-off under Section 428, Cr. P.C.
CHAPTER 65
Human Rights of Prisoners and Jail Reforms
GENERAL
1. Extended meaning of "Life"—
OVERCROWDING IN JAILS
2. Overcrowding of prisons
3. One man in one cell in prison
4. Problem of overcrowding—Remedial measures
RIGHTS OF PRISONERS
5. Solitary confinement of prisoners
6. Convicts not wholly denuded of their fundamental rights
7. Transfer of under-trial prisoners from one Jail to another
8. Complaints of insubstantial food and inadequate clothing
9. Facility of home food to prisoners
10. Medical treatment of prisoners
11. Health of prisoners—Society’s obligations
12. Right of reading and writing available to a prisoner
13. Prisoner entitled to send welfare letters to prisoners in the other prisons whether such prisoners are his relative or not
14. Attendance of prisoner—Can or cannot be procured to answer the charge in investigation ?
ACCESS TO INFORMATION AND
INTERVIEW
OF PRISONERS
15. Communication needs of prisoners
16. Citizen’s access to information and interviews with prisoners—To be controlled and regulated
17. One interview with family members—Legality of the rule
18. Removal of document from jail
HARD LABOUR AND COMPENSATION
19. Hard labour is a part of punishment
20. Equitable wages to prisoners
21. Deduction of expenses from the wages of prisoners by the State
TORTURE AND INHUMAN TREATMENT
22. Inhuman treatment and oppressive measures
23. Leg-irons to under-trials—Prohibition of
PRISON VICES
24. Vices amongst prisoners
PRISON REFORMS
25. Reform in prisons and prisoner by Commission
26. Prison visits—Categories of
27. Appointment of non-official visitors to check mal-administration
28. Prevention of diseases amongst prisoners
29. Open air prisons
PREMATURE RELEASE
30. Premature release—Guidelines
RELEASE OF UNDER-TRIAL PRISONERS
31. Release of under-trial prisoners on bail
PAROLE AND FURLOUGH
32. Parole—Grant of
33. Accused sentenced to undergo life imprisonment under Section 302 and seven years’ imprisonment under Section 397—Right of furlough
34. Grant of furlough
35. Parole during pendency of appeal
36. Recividism—Check of
37. Right of release on furlough—A substantial and legal right
38. Parole or furlough—Breach of conditions
REMISSION
39. Remission in sentence—Right to grant
40. Remission—Grant of
41. Claim of remission
42. Remission of sentence
43. Remission of sentence and gravity of offence
44. Remission dependent on good conduct of prisoner
45. Remission in sentence—Discrimination in
46. Age factor—Acceptable and reasonable basis for classification for remission
47. Benefit of remission—Not available for bail period
48. Set off in case of sentence of life imprisonment
49. Forfeiture or cut in remission
50. Cancellation of remission on when prisoner convicted.
51. Effect of pardon/remission of sentence
52. Power of Court to interfere
PREVENTIVE DETENTION
53. Illegality of detention
54. Non-production of under-trial prisoner in Courts on remand dates
EXECUTION OF DEATH SENTENCE
55. Inhuman treatment before execution of death sentence
COMPENSATION BY ACCUSED
56. Justice to victim of crime
57. Compensation to victims of offence
CHAPTER 66
Voting Rights of Prisoners
1. General
2. Provisions in election law to exclude persons with criminal background
3. Restriction on voting of a prisoner
CHAPTER 67
Compensation for Violation of Human Rights
1. Promissory estoppel
2. Immunity of State for its sovereign acts
3. Sovereign and non-sovereign functions—Distinction between
4. Test for sovereign and non-sovereign functions
5. Change in concept of sovereign immunity
6. Natural justice
7. Abuse of power by public authorities
8. Negligent act of Government officials
9. Compensation—Concept of
10. Compensation—Object of
11. Claim in public law for compensation for unconstitutional deprivation of fundamental rights
12. Quantum of compensation
13. Use of third degree methods and torture by police
14. Speedy trial and plea of financial constraints
CHAPTER 68
Words, Phrases and Legal Terms
1. Accusation
2. Adoption
3. Amenity
4. Anticipatory Bail
5. Anticipatory bail and ordinary bail—Distinction between
6. "Any aggrieved person"
7. "Audi alteram partem"
8. Authority
9. Backward
10. Backward class
11. Bail
12. Banking
13. Begging
14. Caste
15. Class
16. Community
17. Compassion
18. Compensation
19. "Compensation" and "claim for damages"—Distinction between
20. Consent search
21. Copyright
22. Copyright—Infringement of
23. Court
24. Crime
25. Cruelty
26. Decision
27. Design
28. Detain
29. Distribution
30. Dowry death
31. Elector
32. Electorate
33. Forest
34. Furlough
35. "Furlough" and "Parole"—Distinguished
36. Goods
37. Habitually
38. "Hire" and "Avails of"
39. "Human dignity"
40. Human Rights
41. Iddat period
42. Immunity
43. Judicial review
44. Literary work
45. Litigation
46. Maintenance
47. Mental cruelty
48. Noise and noise pollution
49. Parole
50. Pollution
51. "Procedure"
52. Proceedings
53. Prohibit
54. Prosecution
55. Provision
56. Public building
57. Public interest
58. Public way
59. Punished
60. Ragging
61. "Rape"
62. Reasonable classification
63. Regulate
64. Religious minority
65. Remand
66. Remit
67. Repeal
68. Repeal and Amendment—Explained
69. "Reserving a right" and "exercise of a right"—Distinction between
70. Review
71. "Right to life"
72. Search
73. Search and seizure
74. "Self-incrimination"
75. Service
76. Speedy trial
77. State
78. Substantial evidence
79. Suicide
80. Superannuation
81. Terrorist act
82. Vested
83. "Void" and "Voidable"—Distinction between
APPENDIX 1 The Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993
APPENDIX 2 The National Human Rights Commission(Procedure) Regulations, 1994
APPENDIX 3 Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948
APPENDIX 4 International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, 1966
APPENDIX 5 International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966
Appendix 6 International Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Racial Discrimination, 1966
Appendix 7 American Convention of Human Rights, 1969
Appendix 8 African Charter on Human Rights and Peoples’ Rights, 1981
Appendix 9 Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (1966)
Appendix 10 Second Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, Aiming at the Abolition of Death Penalty (1989)
Appendix 11 Instrument of Accession by India to the Human Rights Covenants (1979)
Appendix 12 The National Commission for Minorities Act, 1992
Appendix 13 The National Commission For Minority Educational Institutions Act, 2004
APPENDIX 14 The National Commission for Women Act, 1990
APPENDIX 15 The Protection of Women From Domestic Violence Act, 2005
APPENDIX 16 The National Commission for Backward Classes Act, 1993
APPENDIX 17 The National Commission for Safai Karamcharis Act, 1993
APPENDIX 18 The Commission of Sati (Prevention) Act, 1987
APPENDIX 19 The Commission of Sati (Prevention) Rules, 1988
APPENDIX 20 The Commissions for Protection of Child Rights Act, 2005
APPENDIX 21 Constitution of India
APPENDIX 22 The Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955
APPENDIX 23 The Protection of Civil Rights Rules, 1977
APPENDIX 24 The Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention ofAtrocities) Act, 1989
APPENDIX 25 Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention ofAtrocities) Rules, 1995
APPENDIX 26 The Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Act, 1995
APPENDIX 27 The Persons with Disabilities (Equal Protection of Opportunities, Rights and Full Participation) Rules, 1996
APPENDIX 28 The Pre-Natal Diagnostic Techniques (Regulation and Prevention of Misuse) Act, 1994
APPENDIX 29 The Consumer Protection Act, 1986
APPENDIX 30 The Right to Information Act, 2005
APPENDIX 31 The Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006
Subject- index